Barcaforum Man of the Match 2016/17

bismp said:

Points per 90 minutes:

Messi 48,17
Arda 19,58
Iniesta 18,84
Roberto 17,17
Pique 14,44
Suarez 12,6
Neymar 12,05
Rafinha 11,75
Rakitic 11,06
Umtiti 8,48
Mascherano 7,95
Denis 6,85
Alba 4,7
Gomes 4,67
Vidal 3
Busquets 2,77
MAtS 2,43
Digne 1,5
Mathieu 1,3
Paco 0,13

Click to expand...

LeeRomeno said:

Hilarious how "sell" Arda looks to be our second-third best player of the season lol. Even better than Iniesta with points per 90 minutes lol. Suggestions, maybe we can also add FLOP of the match voting (top 3) and then it is perhaps better to judge overall performance?

Click to expand...

bismp said:

I think that adding 3 Flops per patch would be too much.I certainly won't be able to handle it.But maybe, TOP 3 and 1 FLOP?

On the other hand,it wouldn't be fair,as we are 1/3 into the season.

Besides,how would the flop system work?By retracting points?

Click to expand...

Bojan said:

Arda played vs. 4th division team, twice. Also, voting this season so far was often about who was less bad and not deciding between great performers.

Click to expand...

LeeRomeno said:

Something like that. Idea is similar with elections with "negative votes". So u go and vote for politican you like most and also give "dislike" vote and the ones who get most positive - negative votes, will win Just to make the table more "fair" i guess. So that Arda that owns games vs weaker opposition does not end up being top3 players according to this poll, while infact he has choked alot in important games. Those negative votes would balance it out a bit.

Click to expand...

bismp said:

Hmm i like it.I can also keep count of the "pure positive" points as well as the "final" points(Positive minus Negative).But as i said,because i already kinda struggle,let's limit the Flop votes to 1 per person.For example:

Barca vs Athletic

1.Messi
2.Iniesta
3.Suarez

HM:Busi

Flop:Ney


In the end the results could look like this:

Barca vs Athletic-CDR-Away
Man of the Match

1.Messi: 30 points
2.Iniesta 26 points
3.Suarez 14 points
4.Mats 6 points
5.Ney 5 points
6.Alba: 3 points

14 people voted

Congratulations to Messi blah blah blah

Flop of the Match
1.Ney: -9 points
2.Arda: -3 points
3.Vidal: -2 points

14 votes again,but this time,each member gives one negative vote,instaed of 6(3xgold+2xsilver+1xbronze)

Ney won his 3rd Flop medal of the season blah blah blah


So,in the end Ney would have 5 positive points,9 negative points and one flop medal.But i don't really like the idea of retracting points.Because in the end,a good but incosistent player,will be equal with a bad player.

For example:

Ney 500 positive points -400 flop points= 100 total points
Dunno, Vidal 150 positive points-50 flop points= 100 total points


Dunno,maybe if the mods and the normal members like the idea,i will integrate it.

Click to expand...