Malcom

CatalinR10

Senior Member
If this is his actual level and if he plays like this on majority of days on training grounds, it is way clearer why EV didn't use him too much during a season.

Even though people often asked: did he sleep with EV's wife or something?

Maybe was EV right again in his estimations, hmm...

yes , Valverde decided to bench him after being the best man and scoring vs Real Madrid because he didn't do well the next day in trainings.
 

raskolnikov

Well-known member
yes , Valverde decided to bench him after being the best man and scoring vs Real Madrid because he didn't do well the next day in trainings.
Wouldnt be surprised if we still end up with Willian like Valverde wanted next year. Along with benching Frenkie for workhorses smh.
 

BBZ8800

Senior Member
What do you expect ?
When he’s played well he just gets dropped for weeks afterwards.

His confidence must be shot

If he'll play well and get more chances, then you'll need to bench Coutinho and Dembele.
Then their confidence will be crap.
What then?

This is Barca, we have 2-3 players playing on the same position.

Poor Semedo, his confidence is poor.
Poor Arthur, his confidence is poor.
Poor Dembele, his confidence is poor.
Poor Malcom, his confidence is poor.

Should we ask Uefa to allow us to play with 18 players instead of 11?
Since, otherwise, you know, a lot of our players will be hurt and they'll cry.

Btw. Vidal is usually a 4th pick, but always gives 120% when he gets a chance.

Yet, some other guys give 20% when they DO get a chance.

But, EV is always guilty for everything...
 

khaled_a_d

Senior Member
If this is his actual level and if he plays like this on majority of days on training grounds, it is way clearer why EV didn't use him too much during a season.

Even though people often asked: did he sleep with EV's wife or something?

Maybe was EV right again in his estimations, hmm...

tbh he looks more like a Pedro level of player. He can't carry an attack and if asked to do so he will look awful, but as supporting player he can do well with his speed.
He still need to improve his finishing though
 

jairzinho

Senior Member
He is much better than what we've seen so far but maybe here is not the best place for him.

Needs playing time to continue his development. Either we sell or loan.

The hate from keyboard warriors who have never kicked a ball in their lifetime is harsh.

Ok, so maybe he will be a dud like Sandro, Deulofeu or Adama, or develop late like a De Bruyne or salah.

Who knows?
 

jairzinho

Senior Member
I said somewhere before that there is no place in this team for developing or 'growing' players under Valverde.

Malcolm, Aleñá, Puig etc. No fault of him it's just his coaching style.

combined with the fact that he prefers smaller squads and little rotation.

So as long as he is here, we should focus more on acquiring seasoned players who are ready right away to contribute at a high level.

Players who need the time to adapt and grow, no. Maybe with klopp or some other coach but not here with valverde.
 

serghei

Senior Member
tbh he looks more like a Pedro level of player. He can't carry an attack and if asked to do so he will look awful, but as supporting player he can do well with his speed.
He still need to improve his finishing though

That is exactly what he is. A top squad player who can impact a match even against top sides, like he did vs Madrid, Inter and Atletico. He is not great enough to carry a mediocre attack on his own, but very few players are, and those who can do that cost far more than the 40m. we paid for him.
 

MTL_Barca

Well-known member
If he'll play well and get more chances, then you'll need to bench Coutinho and Dembele.
Then their confidence will be crap.
What then?

This is Barca, we have 2-3 players playing on the same position.

Poor Semedo, his confidence is poor.
Poor Arthur, his confidence is poor.
Poor Dembele, his confidence is poor.
Poor Malcom, his confidence is poor.

Should we ask Uefa to allow us to play with 18 players instead of 11?
Since, otherwise, you know, a lot of our players will be hurt and they'll cry.

Btw. Vidal is usually a 4th pick, but always gives 120% when he gets a chance.

Yet, some other guys give 20% when they DO get a chance.

But, EV is always guilty for everything...

Come on you damn well know Valverde could've given him some more minutes in parts of this season. Even GOATverde isn't flawless.
 

Centauri B

New member
If he'll play well and get more chances, then you'll need to bench Coutinho and Dembele.
Then their confidence will be crap.
What then?

This is Barca, we have 2-3 players playing on the same position.

Poor Semedo, his confidence is poor.
Poor Arthur, his confidence is poor.
Poor Dembele, his confidence is poor.
Poor Malcom, his confidence is poor.

Should we ask Uefa to allow us to play with 18 players instead of 11?
Since, otherwise, you know, a lot of our players will be hurt and they'll cry.

Btw. Vidal is usually a 4th pick, but always gives 120% when he gets a chance.

Yet, some other guys give 20% when they DO get a chance.

But, EV is always guilty for everything...

Exactly. If you want to make it at the best club in the world, you have to be ready to perform when the manager asks you to. No ifs or buts.
 

Arizona Scott

New member
I said somewhere before that there is no place in this team for developing or 'growing' players under Valverde.

I would have swore Lenglet, Arthur, and Dembele got all the minutes they could physicialy handle. Seems like if your young, and very very good, there are plenty of opps.
 

ManusXavi

New member
Less pressure if he starts the match. Imagine coming on at extra time Liverpool 3-0 (3-0 not gonna happen anyway but still).
We need to use him at some point in the match and I would rather the first half
 

Arizona Scott

New member
Less pressure if he starts the match. Imagine coming on at extra time Liverpool 3-0 (3-0 not gonna happen anyway but still).
We need to use him at some point in the match and I would rather the first half

I really doubt he will play. Sergi and alena are more likely options to sub for coutinho.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top