18 - Gerard Martín

Poor Martin sold a free goal but I mean can you imagine how he plays at some random teams and suddenly is starting at Barca how tf does that happen of course he is getting exposed he isn't supposed to be this type of player and considering that he still does ok. Kinda crazy in a backhanded compliment type of way
 
Stop writing stupid stuff.

Do you really watch games or are you browsing elsewhere?

Yes that was a mistake in the 1st madrid goal, but he was BY FAR our best defender the whole game with crucial interceptions.
Cubarsi on the contrary was meh, and really fucked up with Camavinga on the 2nd
I am not even gonna talk about Cancelo
Congrats for being better than other dogshit players

These are the standards we aspire for

"He fucked up but so did the other guy'
 
Scored them a goal but he had a decent intervention on Bellingham. I mean he is not at fault for this loss, not even for being a starter CB
 
Congrats for being better than other dogshit players

These are the standards we aspire for

"He fucked up but so did the other guy'

Let me put it better.

He had a solid game, and was our best defender. Watch his compilation and apart from the 0-1 you will agree with me
 
Let me put it better.

He had a solid game, and was our best defender. Watch his compilation and apart from the 0-1 you will agree with me

And the clearance to Dictator? I'm sure he did have some solid moments here and there but he shouldn't be a long term solution for that position. He most likely wouldn't start for any top club in Europe, whether at CB or LB. Not even midtable prem clubs.
 
I think every CB will get screwed by Flick's tactics, maybe only more speed will help but our CBs aren't slow either.

It's just a reality, we win by outscoring the opponent, recently Yamal has been inconsistent, Raphinha coming back from injury, and the others aren't good enough to decide a game by themselves.

I think the defense is an easy excuse, but in reality our attack let us down against both PSG and Madrid.
 
Defensively Cubarsi had a worse game compared to Martin. Both were responsible for the goals Real Madrid scored.

The excuse on Cubarsi is that he played with fever. If you believe the club.
 
I think every CB will get screwed by Flick's tactics, maybe only more speed will help but our CBs aren't slow either.

It's just a reality, we win by outscoring the opponent, recently Yamal has been inconsistent, Raphinha coming back from injury, and the others aren't good enough to decide a game by themselves.

I think the defense is an easy excuse, but in reality our attack let us down against both PSG and Madrid.

Yes, but only within our framework that we willingly adopted ourselves. It's not something imposed on us, but a risk we gladly and foolishly take.

By that metric what did Guler and Diomande do? They had to do far less than what we ask of our offensive players. Diomande had a chance and scuffed it, had some dribbles, some lost balls. Nothing special, just used his pace after we handed him space to run into. I mean surely he will run into space, that's a bare minimum to expect a fast player to do in a match like this.

Point is we made it easy for their attackers to create more damage with not much. They did the opposite. Was just a botched game on every level. By comparison we ask our striker to press high, exhaust themselves constantly, and then when they hit bad form they are to blame. Not to excuse Yamal who was a black hole with exactly one exception over 90 mins, the shot he put slightly wide.
 
Us being so bad and still having angles to win the game gives me hope. About the only positive thing. That at our worst Madrid still needed some luck to snatch a win.
 
A very lowcost (no fee + low wage) defender who was pulled by Hansi to the first team more out of necessity, than talent. For this, he even overperforms and certainly does what he can.
That said, he should maximum be a rotation CB, especially in the big games. We need another starter LCB alongside Cubarsi, there is zero doubt.
 
I think that was very much a Jude brainfart rather than some Martin masterclass in defending.

Jude had loads of space and time to give that pass to Mbappe. He just didn't, for whatever reason.

Martin did his job though, absolutely. And he does deserve praise for that.
 

This is a perfect summary of the performance of our 2 CBs

Cubarsi rushes for no reason at all, when there is a 2 v 2 at the back, and makes a terrible mistimed tackle that leaves MArtin 1 against 2
Martin on the contrary holds back and covers his back as much as he can in the circumstances

It's ridiculous that Martin always gets all the blame, while all of Cubarsi's mistakes are whitewashed
 
Back
Top