England

How far will they go in WC?

  • Final

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Quarter final

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • R16

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Earlier exit

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    1
  • Poll closed .
After the goal there was no midfield. The entire area was ceded into a flat back five with the midfielders practically on top of the CBs. Messi was great, but he was allowed to be. It's a combination of a few things, mainly:

- the psychology of these players lends itself to protecting a lead and dropping back
- the profile of midfield Tuchel picked in terms of squad composition
- the substitutions Tuchel chose that made the midfield unable to function

Anderson is a Caicedo type, he is not a controller, he wins the ball and plays it. Rice is similar except more physical, better delivery but less brave on the ball. The rationale behind this midfield is that you press from the front and you don't let the opponent breathe, which isn't ideal for these conditions but it can at least function when you have the players in more forward positions that will a) press high for you and b) maintain a threat in behind.

Once you take off Gordon with no Madueke, Watkins or Saka in sight there is no threat in behind and no price Argentina has to pay for their high press. Suddenly you have a midfield that is prone to dropping already, without the pausa to play out of trouble and absolutely no out ball even if they win it back. What you're left with is basically a couple of runners shuffling from side to side with Kane and Bellingham in front of them with no one to pass to.

There was nothing stopping Tuchel from putting players like MLS, Wharton, Jones, Scott, Mainoo etc. into his midfield but I think he wagered that putting in Rice and Anderson who are reliably 8/10 at their very specific (but maybe limited) roles was safer than putting a Wharton or an MLS in there who are more approporiate in terms of profile but are just not on the same level as some of the midfielders they're going to come up against of the same type later in the tournament. In the end Tuchel become more stereiotypically English than the English and did things that I think even an English coach would be too bashful to do. For Southgate Mainoo started a final against Spain, for Tuchel - zero minutes, even fewer than Jordan fucking Henderson.

This is in part why I want Carsley as manager. He will pick a "softer" midfield as people in England will see it because he has no anxiety at all about which players belong in which positions. His U21 Euro winning teams had Curtis Jones and Angel Gomes the first time around, and Anderson and Scott most recently. In fact even during his spell as an interim for the senior job he used 5'6 Gomes in the #6. Obvioulsy I accept these players are not world class, but "square pegs in round holes" has always been one of England's main problems and I see no point in exacerbating it. It's not like whoever wins the whole thing will have world class players in every position.
 
National Team managers don't change decades-long, embedded playing ideologies, or fix natural fears that appear when players are subjected to playing conditions well beyond their ability and knowledge about the game.

England players are good in an athletic way, but the technical levels on display by some Argentina players, especially Messi, but also 2-3 others, was the thing that made them panic. You could feel that when Argentina went at them, they kicked in a gear above England's possibilities to deal with.

The manager's role is starting to get really overstated. It kicks in AFTER you have players of the right formation in place. A top manager isn't going to elevate players in such a big way that they routinely start to do things they've spend 10-15 years of football formation ignoring (because of the they were brought up through the academies and junior years).

That sort of stuff just doesn't get fix anywhere near as easily as some believe. On this end of the argument, Tuchel didn't do anything wrong.

England fans should point fingers at the star attitude of some components of their squad. If they actually embraced the rigors of proper defensive football they could have coped better with the Argentina forcing. But they didn't know how to because to defend well you need realism and humility.
 
Last edited:

I agree with the overall idea, but I think he misses some details too. Owen was fairly gifted technically as a forward too, and he ended his career early like most gifted ones, Joe Cole was also fairly decent, albeit being full of himself.

And it is kind of amusing that both Olise (born and raised in England) , and Musiala who lived there since the age of 7, have chosen other countries they aren't even closely connected to. Both are 2 of the most gifted players born in the early 2000's.

But tbf, England is currently having it's best ever run as NT, since being knocked out by Iceland in Euro 2016, they had 2 Euro finals, 2 World Cup semifinals, 1 World Cup QF. They are missing the title, but otherwise it is the best run in their history.
 
Last edited:
I agree with the overall idea, but I think he misses some details too. Owen was fairly gifted technically as a forward too, and he ended his career early like most gifted ones, Joe Cole was also fairly decent, albeit being full of himself.

And it us kind of amusing that both Olise (born and raised in England) , and Musiala who lived there since the age of 7, have chosen other countries they aren't even closely connected to. Both are 2 of the most gifted players born in the early 2000's.

But tbf, England is currently having it's best ever run as NT, since being knocked out by Iceland in Euro 2016, they had 2 Euro finals, 2 World Cup semifinals, 1 World Cup QF. They are missing the title, but otherwise it us the best run in their history.
Yeah, I think it's mostly in the midfield that he's referring to.

Get that right and I think England will be considered higher as a favorite for a tournament.
 
Germany had a similar buildup from 2006 to 2014, always something in the way.

England are on the right track with a generation coming of age. Except for no.9.
 
National Team managers don't change decades-long, embedded playing ideologies, or fix natural fears that appear when players are subjected to playing conditions well beyond their ability and knowledge about the game.

England players are good in an athletic way, but the technical levels on display by some Argentina players, especially Messi, but also 2-3 others, was the thing that made them panic. You could feel that when Argentina went at them, they kicked in a gear above England's possibilities to deal with.

The manager's role is starting to get really overstated. It kicks in AFTER you have players of the right formation in place. A top manager isn't going to elevate players in such a big way that they routinely start to do things they've spend 10-15 years of football formation ignoring (because of the they were brought up through the academies and junior years).

That sort of stuff just doesn't get fix anywhere near as easily as some believe. On this end of the argument, Tuchel didn't do anything wrong.

England fans should point fingers at the star attitude of some components of their squad. If they actually embraced the rigors of proper defensive football they could have coped better with the Argentina forcing. But they didn't know how to because to defend well you need realism and humility.

England have done the same thing against worse teams than Argentina. It’s a mentality thing. They tried to hang on to a 1-0 lead against Italy at Wembley some years ago. In the Euros final against Spain they stopped playing as soon as they equalised, and then conceded again. I think most of us knew what would happen against Argentina if we didn’t score a second quickly, and we had the chance to do so. Only this time time once Argentina equalised we no longer had the right players on the pitch to suddenly go into attack mode.

But it shouldn’t be forgot that everything was in Argentina’s favour. They had the conditions. They had 80% of their fans inside the stadium, essentially making it a home game. And they had the Messi effect, knowing it was his last tournament.

England overall did pretty well though to essentially finish 3rd with a squad nobody else other than Tuchel would have picked.
 
Back
Top