19 - Lamine Yamal

Alik

Moderator
Was Santos Neymar more talented than current Yamal? I don't think so. Neymar was more of a trickster but Yamal now is already world class at decision making. Very good dribbler, also can be tricky one though not as much as Neymar.

Bear in mind that Yamal is just a 17 years old boy. He is already world class player, performs week in week out.
Neymar was not just a trickster. He scored 136 goals for santos in 225 appearances. Won the the Copa Libertadores whilst being MVP.
 

vegitot

Senior Member
Neymar was not just a trickster. He scored 136 goals for santos in 225 appearances. Won the the Copa Libertadores whilst being MVP.
Yamal also is one of Euro 2024 MVP. And he plays in much tougher, stronger league. Vitor Roque or Endrick looked like beast in Brazil.

Not disrespect Neymar and Brazil league btw. He is of course one of most gifted player ever.
 

Horatio

You're welcome
Something has to be said about yamals vision and footballing iq tho. At his age might be better than neymar.
 

Gazzznigga

Active member
Never seen so much delusion in one thread....Yamal at the best he has played so far is not even close to Neymar at Santos....talk more of the Barcelona Neymar, stylewise or any other ramification.....and i know this would irk a lot here.
 
Last edited:

jamrock

Senior Member
Never seen so much delusion in one thread....Yamal at the best he has played so far is not even close to Neymar at Santos....talk more of the Barcelona Neymar, stylewise or any other ramification.
What?
What?
What????

European Champion yamal?

Or did you mistake him with Bobby Charlton?.
 

Fati_Future_BallonDor

Well-known member
Yamal is better than Santos Ney imo because when Ney came in 13/14 to Barca, he wasnt as good as Lamine is now at 17. Ney was even a few years older in 2013.

Ney exploded in 14/15 and then reached a level which is higher than Lamine's current level, we will see in a few years how much Lamine is able to improve.
 

Gazzznigga

Active member
Yamal is better than Santos Ney imo because when Ney came in 13/14 to Barca, he wasnt as good as Lamine is now at 17. Ney was even a few years older in 2013.

Ney exploded in 14/15 and then reached a level which is higher than Lamine's current level, we will see in a few years how much Lamine is able to improve.
Lol.....Neymar was knocking on the door of BDR while at Santos and playing in a comparatively less fancied league. He was 5th in 2013 BDR ranking when Messi, Ronaldo, Ribbery and Iniesta(only the first 3 and Ibra were ranked higher) were at their prime.

It is understood if you all need a new poster boy to suck up to now given how low the bar has been dropped in recent years but being delusional and hilariously amnesiac about it is comedic.
 
Last edited:

jamrock

Senior Member
Lol.....Neymar was knocking on the door of BDR while at Santos and playing in a comparatively less fancied league. He was 5th in 2013 BDR ranking when Messi, Ronaldo, Ribbery and Iniesta(only the first 3 and Ibra were ranked higher) were at their prime.

It is understood if you all need a new poster boy to suck up to now giving how low the bar has been dropped in recent years but being delusional and hilariously amnesiac about it is comedic.
Be total honest, how many games of neymar did you watch in Brazil?.
 

jamrock

Senior Member
Lol.....Neymar was knocking on the door of BDR while at Santos and playing in a comparatively less fancied league. He was 5th in 2013 BDR ranking when Messi, Ronaldo, Ribbery and Iniesta(only the first 3 and Ibra were ranked higher) were at their prime.

It is understood if you all need a new poster boy to suck up to now given how low the bar has been dropped in recent years but being delusional and hilariously amnesiac about it is comedic.
So basically you didn't watch any/very few neymar games in Brazil.

Figured, lol.
 

Masetro10

Member
Neymar was in the Balon Dor rankings at Santos because he was doing great things at a young age. Voters always fall for that trap. Neymar was a beast for South America no doubt about it. Probably the most hyped young prospect of the 21st century.

But, he was not better than Yamal on accolades at 17. When he joined his first year at Barca wasn't that special. He was learning a new league and club. He may have been more skilled. Maybe a better goalscorer. But Yamal is the type of player that doesn't need stats necessarily to be a contributing factor to winning. Spain Euro puts him comfortably ahead as a player. Doesn't mean Neymar wasn't better than him in all the flashy departments.
 

Gazzznigga

Active member
Neymar was in the Balon Dor rankings at Santos because he was doing great things at a young age. Voters always fall for that trap. Neymar was a beast for South America no doubt about it. Probably the most hyped young prospect of the 21st century.

But, he was not better than Yamal on accolades at 17. When he joined his first year at Barca wasn't that special. He was learning a new league and club. He may have been more skilled. Maybe a better goalscorer. But Yamal is the type of player that doesn't need stats necessarily to be a contributing factor to winning. Spain Euro puts him comfortably ahead as a player. Doesn't mean Neymar wasn't better than him in all the flashy departments.
You more or less corroborated my points.
 

Andresito

Senior Member
Staff member
Neymar also had a strong Confederations Cup win in 2013 which contributed to a boost in Bdor ranking. But he was 21 back then, 4 years older than Yamal. Would bet Yamal will have a golden ball by then. And will be interesting to see where Yamal ends up in the ranking 2024, surely top 10.

Current Yamal has fewer rough edges compared to that Neymar, perhaps it's an effect of being adapted to European football.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top