Xavi has made numerous poor decisions this season including in the first leg of this tie by starting Alonso/Alba and putting Araujo RB and ripping our defence apart.
Xavi is/was my favourite player at the club and I'll never feel a bad emotion toward him but as our coach, I'm not nearly as optimistic as you are.
He's showing high levels of naivity in Europe.
The first leg XI was super mystifying, totally agree there. That is what I meant by being too trusting.
He keeps falling into this fallacy of experience in these big, important matches instead of just trusting what the form and numbers are showing him. Only vet, experienced player I somewhat trust still is Busi (MaTS too if you count him). Other than those two, no one else 30+ deserves a guaranteed spot.
Again, too trusting is his reluctance to react to the match dynamics. I think at times he trusts too much in either the players finding the solutions themselves or our time on the ball to eventually break games in our favor later in the match.
He should have adjusted Araujo first leg to be closer to Rashford, for example. Maybe sub a 3rd forward sooner or start the match with one tonight. His European experience was always a big question mark when he first took the position so I somewhat expected a bit of this.
These are things he can learn however, he is still a very young coach. I will have higher European expectations next season and I wont let what were quite a few factors not in his favor in Europe obscure the good work he is doing.
Its about building a lasting project, not a project that produces one good season and then fades away. If he learns from his mistakes, we solidify our finances so we can improve this squad, I have faith it will produce what we want.
The transfer recruitment, mainly in attack has to improve and quickly however. Im sure the finances are playing a role in this, and we have done decently in MF and DEF but we have 2.5 misses with our attacking acquisitions now and that has to improve this summer. Especially with Ansu not looking the same, we need some sort of quality up front and some shake ups soon.