Pepe vs Pique vs Ramos

[Rassvet]

Debate

 

[Rassvet]

@Temptation
@Fati_Future_BallonDor

 

[Fati_Future_BallonDor]

At pure defending Ramos is last for me

Pepe > Pique even though i think Pique was in his peak better but Pepe's longevity is unmatched in history of football so i take him over Pique

 

[KingLeo10]

Pique's 14/15 is the best peak of the lot.

Ramos most clutch.

Pepe best pure defender.

Hard to separate.

 

[jamrock]

No

 

[Marshall D Teach]

Please do not compare the Portuguese God to those scrubs

Guy's better at 41 than they were at 31

 

[Temptation]

Pepe>Ramos>Pique.


Ramos and Pique are 2 of the most overrated defenders ever by casuals who count team trophies to rate individuals.

 

[Marshall D Teach]

Pepe>Ramos>Pique.


Ramos and Pique are 2 of the most overrated defenders ever by casuals who count team trophies to rate individuals.

Meh they don't hold a candle to the most overrated defender of all time, Thiago Silva.

 

[Morten]

Pepe>Ramos>Pique.


Ramos and Pique are 2 of the most overrated defenders ever by casuals who count team trophies to rate individuals.

No, Ramos and Pique were both excellent players.

Its not just about the trophies, its the contribution to them, Ramos in particular has played a big role in many of the trophies for RM, you talk of him as if he was a passenger.

 

[Morten]

Ramos is overall the better player of the 3, Pepe the best at defending, imo.

 

[Temptation]

No, Ramos and Pique were both excellent players.

Its not just about the trophies, its the contribution to them, Ramos in particular has played a big role in many of the trophies for RM, you talk of him as if he was a passenger.

Excellent? Yes. But they get overrated.


I have seen folks compare Ramos to Maldini and Baresi, which is a joke. At no point in his career, Ramos was as good as them.


But ofcourse, Ramos is an excellent all round player, very clutch and a Madrid legend no doubt.


About Pique, he has glaring weaknesses in his game although he was great in his prime and very good on the ball. Pique has admitted that the PL didn't suit him at all and he found it very difficult. He barely got games ahead of Vidic and Rio. It's because of the weaknesses he had against pace and quick feet. A bit similar to Puyol except Pique was more talented and Puyol had better mental attributes.

 

[mc_lovin]

Neither get close to the Italian Greats, but still miles better than the likes of Van Dijk in todays era.

 

[iniestaGOAT]

RAMOS
PIQUE
PEPE

Next question. Thanks.

 

[Maradona37]

He barely got games ahead of Vidic and Rio. It's because of the weaknesses he had against pace and quick feet.

I know you're gone, but Vidic had the same weaknesses.

 

[companyofcules]

Prime Pique Ramos Pepe
Long run
Pepe Ramos Pique