That is really interesting honestly. None scored that many.
But a key caveat should be mentioned that the only one who really succeeded is Gabriel Jesus and he is precisely known for not being much of a goalscorer.
If his numbers are mirroring his and he becomes a similar level goalscorer without the all around game of Jesus that would be a failure.
It's a small data point but there are a few indicators of how successful a signing will be in Europe.
-Breaking into the first team at 16/17 and staying there
- x amount of G/A (15 or so)
If you watch the videos then Gabriel Jesus definitely had more to his game (just as Rodrygo and Vini did) and Vitor Roque does look more similar to Gabigol as BusiTheKing pointed out.
So it is good that IF Roque continues on these numbers then he is exceeding Gabigol's numbers (I didn't include his 3rd season, but it was only 10 goals iirc) so it looks like there is a higher chance he succeeds.
I think matching Gabriel Jesus numbers is a good sign, Jesus looked a strong finisher and has everything technically but didn't mentality get it together for City. So I think if Vitor Roque doesn't let the pressure of a big team get to him (and let's face it, were one of the worst clubs in the world to put pressure on a striker) then his numbers would transcend well.
I just saw the Bahia lineup (City Group owned) and Kayky, who Man City bought for 10m is back there on loan. So while they can afford to miss trying to get the players early before they have consistently proven themselves in Brasileirao, it seems our approach to wait it out a little bit and pay 20-40m is smarter after they have consistently proven themselves.
BTW, Endrick last year scored 3 in 7 after he debut in the season tail end, and so far this year is on 3 in 9. So he looks like he will put good numbers justifying Madrid's choice to yet again spend a higher amount but go for a super talent. Only failure was Reinier who I suspect if I go back and view the numbers they won't be that strong, and that Madrid just got a bit overzealous after the Vini and Rodrygo successes.