both of you are wrong though, xavi was the undisputed MOtM
Certainly this.
Messi provided 2 excellent assists, and almost another one at the death of the match, but for Villa's miss. But he seems off the pace (due to that silly Copa America I presume)
Cesc scored the 2nd and was involved in the 1st. He is being played out of position, but still shines, but like Messi he is still short fitness-wise.
Xavi was heroic and magic last night. He probed almost all game, he won the ball back countless of times, he executed his brilliant pirouettes to perfection, he distributed the ball in the sublime manner than only he can, he even dribbled for the love of God. All this in a match where Valencia's midfield was crowded and well drilled (led by the more than decent Banega) and all he had as supporting cast was an invisible Keita, and a mediocre Biscuits. Only the introduction of Thiago released some of the suffocating pressure on the old maestro.
It is in games like this one, where things turn out badly, that players of real quality show through. The fact that we drew the game, has no bearing on Xavi's performance. It was one for the ages for anyone who understands football.