Are Barcelona Messi-Dependant?

[gingerless]

not this xavi/iniesta messi thing again

 

[dalitis8]

Absolutely yes.We depend on 3 players.

Fact.

 

[JCCR_FCB]

Well, we can made a list of "dependency":

Here is mine:

1 - Xavi
2 - Messi
3 - Iniesta

 

[Ocurrente]

NO!

 

[dalitis8]

When you have a player like Messi, you might just as well be dependant on him.

 

[Abaddon]

No, a better question would be: is Messi Barca-dependant?

 

[gingerless]

When you have a player like Messi, you might just as well be dependant on him.

/thread

 

[Gevindu]

Are Real Madrid dependent on Ronaldo?

 

[MoFroBo]

Barca aren't dependent on Messi heavily, but ofc. with Messi club has an extra energy. W/o Messi in Barca atm there isn't a very stable goals machine. Too bad Pedro and Bojan this season look like they lost their scoring shoes (seems they are regaining it) and this is major problem why Barca aren't same Barca with Messi (who tends to score two or three goals almost every game).

2-0 w/o Messi
5-0 w/ Mess

The difference is that Barca is more destroying with Messi and that is all. Barca is Barca, atm they only know how to win, with Messi they win only harder, imo

 

[Peerd]

EVERY team is dependant on their 3 best players. Barça are no exception. I actually think we have so many quality in our squad that we are better able to take a injury than other teams.

 

[Elite-BkD]

It depends what you mean by the question. Could they cope if Messi were to leave Barca? Yes. Does he play a pretty huge role for them? Of course, he's Messi.....

 

[Gevindu]

I personally dont think 2 World class strikers can prosper at one club

I really dont want to see Messi injured but if he has a stroke of bad luck and be out for a few months I bet Villa will start raining goals

 

[Jordzibob]

I personally dont think 2 World class strikers can prosper at one club

I really dont want to see Messi injured but if he has a stroke of bad luck and be out for a few months I bet Villa will start raining goals

So what happened in our treble winning season then? What happened with Ronaldo and Higuain last season? Just two, most recent examples, to prove you wrong.

 

[rolminmaminov]

I think dependant to Barcelona's philosophy.