Barca Forum banner - final vote

[Fourteen]

the top one is sloppy - the fade is just leisurely applied to the side images without any precision and the sides of the image don't blend with the background. the middle one is overcomplicated and the bottom one is too big and sloppily put together as well - the design is good but the text is choppy as fuck and the badge is only half there.

Oooo. Someone is bitter this afternoon.

Top one looks fine, the fade doesn't have to be perfect, it looks fine. Too much going on in the second one, completely agree and Maz's is subtle but very effective. Yours was good also though.

 

[antimadritista]

i voted wrong
i ll choose 3rd but i voted first one. :sad:

 

[Metaphysical]

not bitter (well maybe a little) but mainly just unleashing my criticisms on them, where I kept quiet during the previous poll.

maz's is lovely but needs sharpening up and possibly resizing.

 

[Cal-FCB]

The 'Barca Forum' is supposed to be choppy writing it's the font no? And the Barca badge is half missing to emphasise the 'FCB' in the middle of it. That's how I take it anyway. You look too deep into this man.

 

[Lemmi]

The bottom one is the best but the text doesn't have to be blurry and I like the partial badge but still think a bit more of it should be in there.

 

[VivaBarca]

Last one but I want the full badge in it.

 

[Monte-Barça]

Bojan I see only 3 banners. Jarzinho's, mine and maz's..

 

[por supuesto]

I would pick the last one, without the words and the badge actually. Just clean and easy.

YES!

 

[Gnegneri]

So, my mom just got home, loaded with stuff from the mall and things. She asked me what I did today. I said i was high fiving with por supuesto. She nodded.

 

[Barcaman]

Bojan I see only 3 banners. Jarzinho's, mine and maz's..

That`s because this is a final vote. Yours and maz`s got most votes in the initial poll and Jairzinho`s banner came too late to include it there.

 

[JCCR_FCB]

I vote the first. It's very symbolic. I like it!

 

[Emily]

I voted for the first one..

 

[Monte-Barça]

That`s because this is a final vote. Yours and maz`s got most votes in the initial poll and Jairzinho`s banner came too late to include it there.

Aha, OK.. Voting going weird so far.. I'm going to join Meta in his protesting.. Hehehehhehee

 

[por supuesto]

Aha, OK.. Voting going weird so far.. I'm going to join Meta in his protesting.. Hehehehhehee

You make awesome banners no doubt, I just like the whole "less is more" feeling of the last one

 

[maz]

The 'Barca Forum' is supposed to be choppy writing it's the font no? And the Barca badge is half missing to emphasise the 'FCB' in the middle of it. That's how I take it anyway. You look too deep into this man.

Yes, i added an effect to make the text like that. I thought the rest of the baner was smooth, shiney and transparent in places that it needed a bit of edgyness about it.

And by the way meta, i know the badge is only half shown. It wasn´t an oversight lol.