Was working so I just watched the recording.
First off, credit fucking Cultural! They played a heck of a game and for a team in the 3rd division to keep roughly a third of the ball throughout the match against us is impressive to say the least. They also didn't just park the bus the entire time, they had good spells on the ball, were organized off the ball and played with intensity but weren't dirty. I really like what they showed as a team and as a club and I hope to see them in La Liga a couple years down the road!
Our class showed through though with the goal at the end but it was a really disjointed game from us with some players shining and others really struggling. Imho...
The Bad:
-Semedo. I've been a big fan of his this season, he has really impressed me on both sides of the ball this season but I don't know where he was tonight. He made from my count about 5 turnovers today, 2 of them leading to dangerous breaks from Cultural. Simply can't happen if he wants to start over Roberto every match. He needed to be a leader today out there and he put us in a lot of trouble instead. Looked just slower of thought than he usually is, maybe took Cultural lightly and I hope this is a wake up call for him that you can't take any opponent lightly.
-Munir. Despite a couple decent runs here and there, and a nice flick pass in the first half, pretty much invisible throughout the entire match and missed an absolute sitter that a striker for a club of our stature should not be missing. Maybe needs more time but I'm just not convinced he can do much for us either as a starter or off the bench. Wouldn't mind seeing him moved on somewhere next summer.
-Denis Suarez. Lot of the same sentiment for him as Munir. His decision making on the ball really confuses me at times, he forces passes that aren't on to try and show something that lead to possession losses and he misses simple passes at times. He is taking time away from players who show a lot more than he does, namely...
The Good:
-Alena, no surprise here. Outside of two giveaways, just oozed class all game. Decision making, spot on. Positionally sound, always moved the ball forward when the opportunity was on. Dribbled when there was space, passed when there wasn't and make penetrative passes to the forwards and dangerous runs of his own. Please oh please, Valverde! PLAY THIS GROWN ASS MAN. Dude is sooo past the B squad, it's clear as day for me and hopefully Valverde took note of this performance as well.
-Vidal. Solid match overall, one of the more senior players who actually played like one. Not bashing Dembele, it was a good ball for the goal, but I expected a bit more out of him today. Vidal played the pivot well though, something I was a bit skeptical about with him. Phil Schoen on Bein Sports mentioned this and he's right: this sort of performance helps his case in getting more minutes from Valverde as a rotation for Busi. At the very least, he can at least see out the last 15-20 mins of a game to give Busi some extra minutes to rest.
-Malcolm. Nothing spectacular but he demonstrated some things today that suggest he deserves at least a couple more appearances off the bench moving forward. What I am most impressed with from his is his link-up play. He is surprisingly crafty with his passes, he setup Munir with a very clever little ball into him in the 1st half that he completely wasted but things like that show me he deserves more time. The pills from outside of the box and dribbles that he showed at Bordeaux will come with more confidence but I think he showed enough to Valverde today to hopefully trust him with more minutes.
I've been very curious how games like these go. Its pretty clear who our starting 11 is this season, now we need to figure out who can be trusted with La Liga matches down the line in March when we are hopefully still battling in the Champions League. Hope Valverde saw a lot of what I saw out there, sorting through who stays/who goes and crucially, developing the players in this group who he does trust really should be the biggest factor in judging him as a coach. If he can get this right and just rest our gala 11 more this season, I think we've already shown this season we should at least get to the semi-finals of the CL.