Cr150
- Thread starter El Flaco
- Start date
- Status
FinBarcelonafan
Well-known member
Nah. It's his overall game.
KingLeo10
Senior Member
For most pundits and serious football followers yes.
For casual fans who just see CL trophies? Nah.
Latschenkiefer
Senior Member
In my GOAT conversations normally appear only three guys. Two of them because of different times, all of them wear the number 10 and none of them is called Cristiano.
Im assuming you arent that old, how do you really rank players from decades back with limited material to go on?
Ranking players from the same era is not that difficult, ranking players from other eras? That is more difficult.
Last edited:
Latschenkiefer
Senior Member
That's why they are part of the conversation.
khaled_a_d
Senior Member
He is taken seriously in the GOAT conversation regardless. Only Barca fans and old school fans ,who think no one in current generation is great, aren't taking him seriously in this conversation.
For me, I don't really like GOAT conversation, but I think no player in the history was more dominant than Messi & CR7.
As what Lampard/Ferdinand/Lineker said in their famous talk couple of years ago, those are 2 players that no matter how big star you are and no matter your ego you can't help but looking to them and say I wish I was like that.
I only really believe in GOAT conversations according to positions, it makes no sense to compare players with entirely different roles than others to each other.
Compare LBs to Lbs, strikers to strikers, number 10s to numbers 10s and so on.
khaled_a_d
Senior Member
Well, the truth is some positions are more important than others in the way they affect the game.
having someone like Messi/CR7 in your team will always enhance your chances to win than having a Buffon/Roberto Carlos.
Never mind that positions are fluid thing. Is Messi a false 9, RW or SS? Was Rijkaard a CB or DM?
Comparisons in general are always difficult, and in many cases not needed.
But it is huge part of sport culture and its talks along transfers. Fans always dream about potential transfers and compare players all the time. More than discussing details of the game.
Don't like it, but as a wise man once said: It is what it is
He's not even the best Ronaldo (he's just been more durable).
It's his longevity that stands him out. Loads of players have played at a similar (or higher level) for maybe a few seasons rather than the 15 years Ronaldo has continued to bang in goals. 07-12 probably his peak in terms of world class performances rather than the raw talent before then and the goal poacher and penalty kick of the last 5 years.
ThwiX
Best midfielder around
So now with the top scorer title out of reach he suddenly takes his first rest of the season? This guy, man. At least make it less obvious how much you care about individual awards and records. Last game was the longest travel of Juve’s domestic season, and even with the league won, he played every single minute. Now, at home against Roma, he is not even on the bench. 
- Status
Home of Barca Fans
