David Silva
- Thread starter Barcaman
- Start date
RedMadridista
The Troll Hunter
No question about it.
As GN said last night.... Mata plays best in the middle...
Chelsea play him as a winger.. Mata's a better 'winger' than Silva though.
La Furia
Legion of Doooom
Mata is a bit more well rounded. Better goalscorer for instance.
Silva is the better player though, because what he's good at is better than anything Mata is good at. Also English defenses have no clue how to deal with him, it's hilarious.
Metaphysical
Bomb Dropper
the man's name is Juan Villas-Welker.
La Furia
Legion of Doooom
antonnn
Blue Blooded Aussie
I agree Silva is better, but not as much as I had originally thought. And I didn't post the picture to say Mata owned Silva or anything, neither had a very good game tbh, just posting it cause I'm a Chelsea fan and he's our Spanish playmaker. 
Admittedly Mata has done A LOT better than I had anticipated, I think his first season is arguably better than Silva's at this same point in the season(though Silva took a while to get into the groove, no?). As far as I know he's only behind Silva in assists(by 1), and scored 1 less goal as well. Fantastic stuff from Sir Juan considering how poor we've been at times and how dominant and free scoring City can be.
Admittedly Mata has done A LOT better than I had anticipated, I think his first season is arguably better than Silva's at this same point in the season(though Silva took a while to get into the groove, no?). As far as I know he's only behind Silva in assists(by 1), and scored 1 less goal as well. Fantastic stuff from Sir Juan considering how poor we've been at times and how dominant and free scoring City can be.
RedMadridista
The Troll Hunter
I would take Silva over Mata all the time.
Silva>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Mata
Silva>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Mata
RedMadridista
The Troll Hunter
LOL. Not a chance.
Nani is better them all.
Nani's the best WINGER in the PL.. Better than that overrated monkey (Bale).
I like Mata a lot though.. he would be excellent in the middle.. I don't know why AVB plays him on the wing.
Last edited:
All you do is claim how a player x is better than player y, but never reason it. Please do share. In this instance, how is Nani the best winger in the PL?
RedMadridista
The Troll Hunter
1) Look at his stats
2) who is better?
Actually.... don't even try an debate it.. It's a well known FACT he's not only the best winger in the PL... he's one of the best wingers in the world.
Get. Over. It.
Last edited:
X
xaviniesta
Guest
Sorry, not a stats person here. I want an in-depth football analysis on the player, his attributes, and in what way he contributes to his team, that others don't for their respective teams etc. If you can't, then you're dumb.
Home of Barca Fans
