Gerard Piqué

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Haha. Xaviesta, Busquets was great 09-11 but that's it. Real midfield much more adaptable, durable and functional especially in cl. Too many nostalgic idiots out here. Fact 8s we underachieved in cl at our peak. Real did the opposite.

Nah the Barca peak was higher and performed at higher level.

You just claimed Barca won 2 of 3 CLs at their peak.

Not much of an under achievement and won treble all there is to win in those seasons etc while taking their country to the WC title and Euros.
 

Barcilliant

Senior Member
Go support RM then. Ain't nobody going to miss your copy/pasta tirades.

Seen one, seen all.

Barca supporter for over thirty years. There's nothing wrong with criticising the club. Been a joke for five seasons with no end in sight and no I'm not interested in n supporting Madrid.
 

Temptation

Well-known member
Barca mid trio reached a higher peak. But I think the Madrid mid has more longevity, are more durable, versatile and clutch. There have been moments when K C M have really shined. The thing is RM's playing style was never to totally dominate ball possesion like Barca's was so that affects the eye test but their off the ball work is kinda underrated.

In terms of success, Madrid trio edges it since we can't include international success in the conversation for obvious reasons.

Barca midfield was more spectacular.

Madrid's midfield showed functionality, guile, longevity and momentary strokes of genius.

Madrid trio has lesser chances of going completely wrong.

No disrespect to any of the 2 midfield. Both amazing.

Let's put it this way: Barca midfield would be remembered more fondly but Madrid's midfield would be remembered more number of times.
 

Barcilliant

Senior Member
Nah the Barca peak was higher and performed at higher level.

You just claimed Barca won 2 of 3 CLs at their peak.

Not much of an under achievement and won treble all there is to win in those seasons etc while taking their country to the WC title and Euros.

Barca peak may have been higher but fizzled out quickly. Madrid midfield have stood the test of time. Noone expected them to win CL but they did it against all odds. Barca midfield were great front runners but lacked the ability to launch any remontadas.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
Xavi was 29 when won first CL as part of that midfield.

Of course Real have more longevity as got together at younger age and Modric has held performances better than any of three did.

But that 2/3 years when Barca midfield dominated in way no other mid has at both club and intl level doesnt compare.
 

Barcilliant

Senior Member
Barca mid trio reached a higher peak. But I think the Madrid mid has more longevity, are more durable, versatile and clutch. There have been moments when K C M have really shined. The thing is RM's playing style was never to totally dominate ball possesion like Barca's was so that affects the eye test but their off the ball work is kinda underrated.

In terms of success, Madrid trio edges it since we can't include international success in the conversation for obvious reasons.

Barca midfield was more spectacular.

Madrid's midfield showed functionality, guile, longevity and momentary strokes of genius.

Madrid trio has lesser chances of going completely wrong.

No disrespect to any of the 2 midfield. Both amazing.

Let's put it this way: Barca midfield would be remembered more fondly but Madrid's midfield would be remembered more number of times.

Good post. Objective and measured. Ball hogging and possession stats are not remembered, trophies are. There were a number of times when Barca looked clueless against parked buses. Madrid always somehow got goals from midfield and defense.
 

Temptation

Well-known member
Barca supporter for over thirty years. There's nothing wrong with criticising the club. Been a joke for five seasons with no end in sight and no I'm not interested in n supporting Madrid.

Good for you mate. Atleast you don't ACTUALLY support Madrid. :lol:

You're a bit pessimistic. You're the fan at the pub who moans about everything. Fair play.
 

Barcilliant

Senior Member
Good for you mate. Atleast you don't ACTUALLY support Madrid. :lol:

You're a bit pessimistic. You're the fan at the pub who moans about everything. Fair play.

If we had respectable exits from Europe we wouldn't have that much whinging. What is so galling about our European defeats has been the manner in which we've been hammered. No big club stands still after getting hammered so many times. We do though.
 

te amo barca

Blaugrana al vent
First it was Zidane, then Ronaldo, then Ramos, then Navas, now it is Madrids midfield trio that is the clutch magic wand? Reductionist and superficial to suggest that. They have (had) a team with more personality than late Pep and Tito?s Barca, simple as that.

Purely as a midfield trio, Busi-Xavi-Iniesta is in another dimension. Busi-Rakitic-Iniesta schooled that midfield all the time ffs.
 

vegitot

Senior Member
So Pique is confident that he can bench even world best CB now.

To be fair when he is concentrated, he looks like one of the best player on the pitch but his mind is not there.
 

serghei

Senior Member
So Pique is confident that he can bench even world best CB now.

To be fair when he is concentrated, he looks like one of the best player on the pitch but his mind is not there.

True. When he's focused he looks like one of the best defenders on the pitch.

When the pitch is filled with defenders from Mallorca and Elche. Plus Lenglet, Garcia or Mingueza.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top