He is delivering so far despite numerous challenges and hasn't moaned or complained once.
True, but the season barely started, and let's see him for some years under these conditions. At the moment, he is going strong, but it's quite normal to be highly motivated early into the job.
This stuff takes its toll on managers in time.
So far, very pleased. The team is playing nice football, picking up valuable points, and he seems closer to a very good manager, making his stint at Germany NT a fluke, and not his fault in my mind.
Need to see him once the team gets into a rough patch, and that's gonna happen sooner or later.
I don't see the need to compare him to Xavi personally. Xavi helmed the team through a phase, did it nicely, couldn't do it anymore, got replaced as it should be.
There's a case to be made that Barca should have accepted 3-4 years of not competing for big titles, and run a different strategy (that's solely Laporta's decision), but can't really fault the club for staying true to its modern status despite lack of proper funds.