Hans-Dieter Flick

Hansi Flick - how do we rate him?


  • Total voters
    104

Loki

Well-known member
VAR/semi-automated offsides made this style of offside trap work well with confidence. Imagine how many borderline calls to continue play would result in goals conceded for us without it
Insane how long football was played without a review option and thus making the game a coinflip. Now they need to introduce effective time, so all that time wasting and simulating injuries stops. How difficult can it be to implement, as nearly any other professional sport has it.
 

khaled_a_d

Senior Member
Now they need to introduce effective time, so all that time wasting and simulating injuries stops.

FIFA has been thinking about it for long, but that one is actually difficult.

Because actual playing time is around 55 minutes per game. Footballers right now can't play 90 minutes effective playing time, and fans would hate it if the game is lasting beyond 3 hours for the sake of it.

So to do it, you have to change football match into 60 minutes, or less, games. And while this looks good, as it is essentially the sane, it will be drastic change to the game. 90 minutes is a football tradition that is hard wired at fans mind atm. So, you can see the hesitation is warranted.

Also, 55 minutes game is weird, 60 minutes game adds another mileage on players, who are already complaining. Never mind airing time implications.

They tried the long added times in the WC, and tbh I enjoyed it, but it seems it was unpopular as they didn't continue with it.
 

Loki

Well-known member
FIFA has been thinking about it for long, but that one is actually difficult.

Because actual playing time is around 55 minutes per game. Footballers right now can't play 90 minutes effective playing time, and fans would hate it if the game is lasting beyond 3 hours for the sake of it.

So to do it, you have to change football match into 60 minutes, or less, games. And while this looks good, as it is essentially the sane, it will be drastic change to the game. 90 minutes is a football tradition that is hard wired at fans mind atm. So, you can see the hesitation is warranted.

Also, 55 minutes game is weird, 60 minutes game adds another mileage on players, who are already complaining. Never mind airing time implications.

They tried the long added times in the WC, and tbh I enjoyed it, but it seems it was unpopular as they didn't continue with it.
I think 60 minutes effective time is good enough. The game will still last around 90-95 minutes, so not much is going to change for the fans. The rest is getting used to.
I remember when Fifa introduced the free kick spray in the World Cup in 2014 and the German commentator back then said, who needs that crap. It only disturbs and distracts from the game.
Now you can't think about the game without it, the same as VAR. It's not perfect, but it made football fairer. It's the same with effective time. No need for extra time anymore, the players can't waste time dragging corner kicks, subs or faking injuries. The popularity will come fast when fans will see how much fairer the game would get. Who doesn't hate it, when the game has 5 minutes extra time and they only play 2 of them, while wasting 3.
Xavi complained about it a lot and he's right. Every other professional sport has it, why not the biggest one with the biggest prizepools? The goal needs to be to make a sport as fair as possible.
 

ZenI

Professor Balthazar
BTW:

1) Punishing Kounde for not coming in time for the pre-match talk, and starting Fort instead.

2) Punishing Lamine for trying to show off, and subbing him out immediately

THAT's the kind of LEADERSHIP this team needs!
Not yes-men like Valverde, not someone treating players like pets that need dinner-rewards and days off like Xavi

MY MANAGER!
He actually subbed Yamal for trying to show off? I missed that, sauce?
 

ZenI

Professor Balthazar
I also saw he was sulking, but thought he simply wasn't happy about his performance (which I still think was very good in the first half and alright in the second).
 

Loki

Well-known member
A 17 year old sulking a bit, never heared of before :lol:
People need to relax about a moody teenager's reaction.
 

jamrock

Senior Member
Flick is doing great, but respect the work of Don Xavi .

View attachment 11135
Just goes to show, we are running on a lot of "vibes" right now, but thus far while we are playing a more attacking style of play, the results aren't much better than last season, where if we had a few better calls, we would probably have 24-27 points after 9 games.

We just need to keep the vibes train going, one big plus is we won't have pena in goal for 10 league games.
 

Barcaman

Administrator
Staff member
Xavi's last season start wasn't too bad either. Plenty of goals too.
Until the Clasico loss that came just around this time.

Maybe we are a bit under new coach spell but I do know Barca wasn't this exciting.

Sevilla, Bayern and Real next will give more answers, sure. But then in November it's also Real Sociedad and Celta Vigo away. It's really one of the hardest first 3 months in recent history. Also with injuries and not having Camp Nou.

Said in August if Flick survives until winter he is safe and so far he's doing great and is, considering the language barrier, surprisingly well liked by entire team and everyone surrounding it.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top