in 2014 (when we signed him) he was really bad until january 2015. Team was bad actually. Neymar, Suarez and Leo was having trouble with Zubizaretta. Board sacked him and suddenly we improved on the field. Lucho also was having trouble with Leo and Suarez and they worked it out. Even Rakitic started to play superb. However I always criticized his style. He scored good amount of goals, his passing was ok, his zonal defence was ok but he wasn't that good. He never was a creative midfielder in Barcelona eventhough he played as attacking midfielder before. And now Valverde counts on him too much. Even when he plays bad which he only played good couple of games this season he always found himself in the starting 11.
EV is a traditional person who always counts on same players, same tactics and never tries to do something new. He even played with Rakitic-Vidal midfield in the first 2 months of this season and what do you know, we played really bad. And then he replaced Vidal with Arthur and suddenly things started to work out. And fast-forward to this last 2 months, Arthur attended Neymar's sisters birthday party before El Clasico and Valverde cut Arthur from the starting 11. Granted Vidal played really good 3-4 games including Liverpool games, Rakitic was nowhere to be seen eventhough he was allegedly on the field. Valverde didn't think of replacing him one second. He didn't use Arthur even after he apologized. He never challenged Rakitic's poor form by replacing him with Arthur nor Alena. And now we have this player in our hand. What are we going to do with him? I don't know. Bartomeu promised De Jong that they will sell Rakitic but then they extended Valverde's contract and Valverde wants Rakitic to stay. Suffice to say, if we had Valverde as our coach back in the day, we wouldn't have xavi-iniesta at all. We need to get rid of Rakitic and we need to get rid of Valverde.