KingLeo10
Senior Member
When you look at Messi within the team, 2009-11 Messi is the best for me, closely followed by 14-15. Now he creates more statistically, but the freedom he has in terms of other duties is huge. During Guardiola, he had to do more in terms of tactics, pressing, positioning. Nobody counts that when judging 'the best Messi'. They look at goals and assist and chances created only.
2010-2011 was his absolute peak. He was churning out top, top performances in terms of goals, assists, dribbling v teams like RM and Man.United.
2014-2015 is his second best season. He had ~120 dribbles in the CL that year (averaging 10 plus dribbles a game against La Liga opponents is one thing but doing it in the CL KO stages is just ludicrous). Took Bayern, City (especially), and Juventus to school.
2011-2012 is statistically his best season ever. I'd put that, 09/10, 08/09 and 12/13 (until that PSG injury) third.
Then 18/19 just slightly behind that. Maybe 16/17 too.
13-14 was the worst Messi. Unfit, all attention on the WC since Jan etc.
I agree that just looking at assists, goals, or chances created is misleading. I absolutely do not buy that the current version of Messi is anywhere near prime Messi. That guy dismantled WC defenders for fun in 1 on 1. I don't see him do that regularly anymore. Only his passing is better than it used to be. Everything else is worse to a lot worse. Still enough to be best in the world (like last season) but not by a landslide. I think him, CR7 (big game scoring), Neyclown (when he's serious and fit) are all in the mix or same level right now.