Again, it sounds like nice guys are a problem. Iniesta for example was a true champion. No one sane would take Van Bommel over him.
We can thankfully still field 11 players, so theres plenty of space for different types of players and personalities.
street boy asshole Neymar
Nice guys win ONLY if they are vastly superior in terms of technique.
Like in once in a lifetime Messi-Xavi-Iniesta-Busi-Alves generation.
If you aren't superior and you are tied on skills with tougher-combative guys, you will mentally crumble in majority of cases like on away matches, in the last 10 minutes etc
No wonder that Barca historically is the worst big European team on away matches.
Because we get bullied and we are more prone to crumble under pressure.
Also, it is not a surprise that Pep's City, who is mostly built aroung technical choirboys guys, crumble under pressure whenever the stakes are high in CL matches.
There is something primal in those matches and in those final do-or-die minutes.
Iirc, since 2008, Barca managed only two last minute clutch wins in 12 years: Chelsea 2009 and Psg 2017.
And even then, street boy asshole Neymar turned the match and not Messi, Busi or Iniesta.
They don't have a nice guy problem, they have a Fernandinho is ageing and Rodri is not good enough problem. Their front line doesn't scare anyone any more either. Sterling is out of form, Agurero and now Jesus are injured, and Mahrez doesn't really offer much threat in behind. They really need to start sitting and countering against teams, but Pep will never do that.
I'd be shocked if he continues with City. He needs a break/new plan. You could see it in his face already one or two years ago. Not the same passion he had the first few years.
City needs a rebuild, thats something Pep really hasnt done before, though he has introduced new players to his teams, replacing an entire core is something else.
Is he a team-builder? Doesnt look like it, Silva, Fernandinho, Yaya, Kompany and Aguero havent really been replaced.
True. He has signed none of the key players.