mark1nhu
New member
I agree with @dakt and I feel bad for saying this but we played better without Neymar. I'm not sure what impact he would have on Carvajal's performance, I see them both as equally good.
It's close to impossible to measure how much we played better DUE TO Neymar's absence or due to other factors (including Madrid's naiveness/dumbness). The same way we can't say how much he was responsible for the remontada against PSG and how the match would turns out without him, even though we know for sure he was important for that.
Anyone trying to splash a dissertation about it here is just making efforts to make it fit personal preferences and agenda (as usual).
There is simply nothing to see here. We played well/decently without him, the same way we played well/decently without other important players on other important matches (like the 4x0 against Madri, when we were simply great, without Messi).
Anyway, before the usual suspects come here to attack me, I would like to say: I am eager to see Lucho out, some better coach coming in and at least 2 world class players to our midfield, so Neymar can focus again on being a lethal winger instead of a playmaking, because he is far from the great player I see when taking this much build-up responsibility.