Muscle injuries, especially hamstring tears for footballers, are mostly due to weakness or fatigue building up.
It's not the case that a player will get a hamstring tear because some physio made him do "less physical preparation" acutely before the game.
In any case, coming off the bench, you are not guided through any physical preparation, but told to warm up on your own on the sideline, so it's Dembeles own fault if he wasn't properly warmed up.
Your claims:
1)
Muscle injuries are due to weakness or fatigue
Not entirely true.
Muscle injuries can happen due to accumulation of playing time, condensed schedules etc
That has never been the case of Dembele.
He never got a muscle injury because he played a lot.
Last season was the inverse confirmation. He played a lot, and did not get any injury the whole of January, February, and March, when he was playing all the time
2)
No player will get a hamstring tear because some physio made him do "less physical preparation" acutely before the game
I am not sure you know that the term 'physical preparation' does not apply to warming up before coming in a game.
It is a much wider term and applies to the kind of exercises the players do every day in training, on the pitch and in the gym.
It refers to stamina exercises, running, but also gym work, building muscle, it involves taking good care of your whole muscular system
3)
It's Dembeles own fault if he wasn't properly warmed up
Ridiculous shit here.
You don't know that he wasn't properly warmed up.
You are making things up to put the blame on the player
At first I thought you were being sarcastic, but then I realized you weren't. Are you seriously blaming EV for Dembele being the most injury prone winger in the sport? That's ridiculous. The guy is injury prone, get over it. It's happened so many times that at the end of the day, you just gotta accept it. It is what it is, move on. These are professional athletes, they get consulting by trainers even outside of the team doctors. Their body is what gives them millions. lol at thinking that ONLY the team doctors and the coach are responsible for them.
Mate, look:
Some players are more injury-prone than others.
And Dembele's muscular system in particular is injury prone. He gets very easily torn in different ways.
Up to here I can agree with you.
Then, there is ton more nuance in it that you overlook.
Dembele didn't have a single muscular injury for 2 years at Rennes and Dortmund.
Then he didn't have a single muscular injury the whole 20-21 at Barca under Koeman.
On the contrary, for 3 years under Ernie he was being injured week in week out.
What changed from Dortmund to Barca, and what changed again from Ernie to Koeman? Think for youself.
You should be able to fill up the missing pieces and deduce that something happening under Valverde was causing Dembele's constant injuries
Or let me help you more: We know from reports that under Ernie the team was not doing any physical preparation. The training sessions were lasting fucking 20 minutes. Do you realize that? That's barely professional...
So, yes
I ABSOLUTELY blame Ernie and his stuff for Dembele's condition those 3 years.
PS: The amount of BS I have read on this thread (like that Dembele at Dortmund did not like to play video games, nor did he like to eat junk food, it all suddenly started at Barca) is insane!
And it is just to shove responsibility off of Ernie's shoulders and put it all on the player himself.
Just because you guys hate him.
Ridiculous!