Paul Pogba
- Thread starter Butaan4barca
- Start date
Sea_of_Frost
Member
MaxY
Devil May Cry
Sea_of_Frost
Member
diegomessi
Anxiously waiting for the next match
Could be the man to take PSG to a CL final.. also can make ALOT of money and win ALOT of french titles... Would be a good move for him.
Jair Ventura
New member
MaxY
Devil May Cry
Let's look at the situation objectively.
RM - A fun league with great competition from Barcelona and ATM. The club with the most revenue and probably the most popular. Considered the pinnacle of football alongside Barcelona. In the semi-finals of the UCL pretty much always.
PSG - A rising club with shitton of money. French league has ABSOLUTELY no competition. The league is won 8 games before the end of the season. 25 points ahead of the 2nd place,an absolute joke of a league.
Aryagorn
Improvin' Perfection!!
Yeah, let's look at it objectively.
Here's a team who jump the gun and buy every other rising star in the league making your stay there a pain in the arse. Ruined the likes of Isco, James, etc.
There's PSG on the other hand. Raised to the stature of strong contenders of CL, accumulated a strong-young team, made Zlatan a legend in less than 5 years and could make you attain an even bigger legendary status considering you could stay their starter for over a decade.
Just imagine you won the CL with Real and then imagine you won the CL with PSG. Which one would you prefer?
Vlom
Previously known as Mehssi
Winning CL with RM (and contributing to it) means you're getting sold right after and all credit goes to CR7 anyway, just ask DiMaria
Aryagorn
Improvin' Perfection!!
haha.... good oneWinning CL with RM (and contributing to it) means you're getting sold right after and all credit goes to CR7 anyway, just ask DiMaria
TornAndFrayed
Banned
RM and PSG are both bad options for Pogba.
Don't even need to argue about RM, maxy made me smile as always.
There is indeed no domestic competition for PSG atm, and Pogba like most french players must be comparatively less enthusiastic about joining PSG than foreign players. It has simply been too long since playing anywhere in France mattered on the european scene. Foreigners don't have this syndrome. PSG is changing that a bit but isn't there yet.
Don't even need to argue about RM, maxy made me smile as always.
There is indeed no domestic competition for PSG atm, and Pogba like most french players must be comparatively less enthusiastic about joining PSG than foreign players. It has simply been too long since playing anywhere in France mattered on the european scene. Foreigners don't have this syndrome. PSG is changing that a bit but isn't there yet.
Jair Ventura
New member
RM - Senile President, inexperienced manager, circus of a transfer policy, regularly ruins developing talents, sells established players that have contributed to the clubs success for political reasons, Barcelona's bitch, etc.
PSG - Suave president with rising profile, fastest growing club in the world, rapidly growing league, awesome developmental set up, etc.
Really, I was trolling. RM or PSG would be good options, as would staying at Juve. I'd personally prefer Thomas Lemar.
Last edited:
BarçaBarça
New member
There is pros and cons for each club, it depends on what he prioritizes really, and we don't quite know that, do we?
Sporting glory?
Might as well stay in Juve: As big a change for CL as PSG in the coming years, and right now bigger than in RM. A La Liga trophy with RM would give him more recognition, though. A move to the PL could be more of a consideration - if Pep builds an awesome ManCity-side, then surely a PL-title would be glorious, but his chances in CL would be lessened. Also if the PSG-project doesn't result in CL-succes, it would be impossible for him to leave it, and he would be stuck in a very bad league.
Fame?
Might as well stay in Juve: He is undisputed starter, and could be a legend in one of Europe's most historic clubs. In PSG he would have a harder time getting recognized for his talent (harder to compare to others with same level, when in a bad league), but surely get attention when he scores screamers or make fantastic assists. In RM he would be famous - a true galactico, in a club with a huge focus on marketing and commercialization (and maybe a Bale-type they would do much to get to work). If he seeks worldwide fame more than sporting glory, RM surely would be the best guarantee of that. With a PL-side could also hype to the best player in the world, if he performs and challenges for the title. In that respect he would get more fame in a PL-side than here in Barca, as he would never be seen as the best in this Barca team - he could be that in the worlds best (hype) league.
Money?
Surely PSG could offer him the most: They are the best paid team in the world! (People tend to forget that - not RM with Ronaldo or Barca with Messi). They would move mountains to get him, but that is also the biggest advantage that PSG have - in my eyes nothing else counts in their favour (maybe stable management, but that is not guaranteed even there - and nowhere else to be exact). RM can compete with their money - and the greater attention could give him more commercial deals, which maybe would make them even. Manchester City could also pay insane amounts.
I don't know if Bayern are interested at all? Sporting glory will be bigger there, if he could establish himself, but the two other factors nearly the same as Juve, I suppose.
I'm not sure if we are interested as well? It seems like he is too expensive for us right now. We don't need him yet - maybe in a year or two, if Iniesta ever declines, but the timing is not good right now (would smash our well-functioning and balanced midfield-depth). I would only take him if he would be ready to earn less than half of what other clubs offer - to show that he is committed, and also less than, lets say Busquets, to know his place in this team. If he isn't ready for that he wouldn't fare well in our team anyway, IMO.
Sporting glory?
Might as well stay in Juve: As big a change for CL as PSG in the coming years, and right now bigger than in RM. A La Liga trophy with RM would give him more recognition, though. A move to the PL could be more of a consideration - if Pep builds an awesome ManCity-side, then surely a PL-title would be glorious, but his chances in CL would be lessened. Also if the PSG-project doesn't result in CL-succes, it would be impossible for him to leave it, and he would be stuck in a very bad league.
Fame?
Might as well stay in Juve: He is undisputed starter, and could be a legend in one of Europe's most historic clubs. In PSG he would have a harder time getting recognized for his talent (harder to compare to others with same level, when in a bad league), but surely get attention when he scores screamers or make fantastic assists. In RM he would be famous - a true galactico, in a club with a huge focus on marketing and commercialization (and maybe a Bale-type they would do much to get to work). If he seeks worldwide fame more than sporting glory, RM surely would be the best guarantee of that. With a PL-side could also hype to the best player in the world, if he performs and challenges for the title. In that respect he would get more fame in a PL-side than here in Barca, as he would never be seen as the best in this Barca team - he could be that in the worlds best (hype) league.
Money?
Surely PSG could offer him the most: They are the best paid team in the world! (People tend to forget that - not RM with Ronaldo or Barca with Messi). They would move mountains to get him, but that is also the biggest advantage that PSG have - in my eyes nothing else counts in their favour (maybe stable management, but that is not guaranteed even there - and nowhere else to be exact). RM can compete with their money - and the greater attention could give him more commercial deals, which maybe would make them even. Manchester City could also pay insane amounts.
I don't know if Bayern are interested at all? Sporting glory will be bigger there, if he could establish himself, but the two other factors nearly the same as Juve, I suppose.
I'm not sure if we are interested as well? It seems like he is too expensive for us right now. We don't need him yet - maybe in a year or two, if Iniesta ever declines, but the timing is not good right now (would smash our well-functioning and balanced midfield-depth). I would only take him if he would be ready to earn less than half of what other clubs offer - to show that he is committed, and also less than, lets say Busquets, to know his place in this team. If he isn't ready for that he wouldn't fare well in our team anyway, IMO.
Home of Barca Fans
