Should I stay or should I go?

[khaled_a_d]

100% SHOULD STAY
3. Piqué
8. Iniesta
10. Messi
11. Neymar
16. Busquets
15. Bartra
18. Alba
2. Montoya

100% SHOULD LEAVE

1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto
25. Oier
9. Alexis


DOUBTFUL

21. Adriano
22. Dani Alves
14. Mascherano
4. Fàbregas
7. Pedro

 

[Pablo89]

If we get 2 good CBs then Masch should leave if a decent offer comes. Else I don't want to see him at CB ever again even if I agree he gives his all.
He has so many shortcomings as a CB. The only reason Masch can remain is if barca chooses to employ d double pivot which I doubt will happen anytime soon.



Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk

 

[Jägermeister]

100% SHOULD STAY
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
7. Pedro
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
10. Messi
11. Neymar
14. Mascherano
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto
25. Oier

DOUBTFUL
22. Dani Alves
2. Montoya
21. Adriano

Well spoken. Just don't sell Adriano and Montoya at the same time.

 

[Semi-Neutral]

100% SHOULD STAY
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba
22. Dani Alves
17. Song
7. Pedro
14. Mascherano

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
19. Afellay
23. Cuenca

DOUBTFUL
2. Montoya
25. Oier
21. Adriano
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
24. Sergi Roberto
20. Tello

Selling as many players as most of you guys are recommending is insane, our team would be really shaken up.

 

[Kobe Bean Bryant]

100% SHOULD STAY
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
7. Pedro
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
11. Neymar
14. Mascherano
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba
21. Adriano
100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
2. Montoya
5. Puyol
6. Xavi
10. Messi
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
22. Alves
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto
25. Oier

 

[Da Silva]

Stay:

Montoya
Pique
Bartra
Alba
Busquets
Cesc
Iniesta
Messi
Neymar
Alexis


Leave:

Martino
Valdes
Pinto
Oier
Puyol
Dos Santos
Afellay
Tello
Bojan
Cuenca


Doubtful:

Alves
Mascherano
Adriano
Song
Xavi
Sergi Roberto
Pedro

 

[Adrian]

100% SHOULD STAY
2. Montoya
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
22. Dani Alves
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto
25. Oier

DOUBTFUL
7. Pedro
14. Mascherano
21. Adriano

 

[Puyol the wall]

100% SHOULD STAY
2. Montoya
3. Piqué
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
10. Messi
11. Neymar
14. Mascherano
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba
22. Alves

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto
25. Oier

DOUBTFUL
4. Cesc
7. Pedro
9. Alexis
21. Adriano

Basically this, I'm convinced that Alexis, cesc and Alves should go too, we need a revamp, nothing against most of our players, just that our squad is pretty much stagnated.

 

[Darko]

Selling as many players as most of you guys are recommending is insane, our team would be really shaken up.

Well it is time to shake thing up, and players like Dos Santos just aren't good enough, even for a backup (and as 3rd choice we can always use the youngsters).

 

[linetty]

100% SHOULD STAY

2. Montoya
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
10. Messi
11. Neymar
16. Busquets
15. Bartra
18. Alba

100% SHOULD LEAVE

1. Valdes
5. Puyol
7. Pedro
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
25. Oier

DOUBTFUL

9. Alexis
14. Mascherano
21. Adriano
22. Dani Alves
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto

 

[Gohan]

100% SHOULD STAY

3. Piqué
8. Iniesta
10. Messi
11. Neymar
16. Busquets
15. Bartra
18. Alba
9. Alexis
21. Adriano

100% SHOULD LEAVE

1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
25. Oier
6. Xavi
14. Mascherano

DOUBTFUL

22. Dani Alves
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto
7. Pedro

 

[Pepe Silvia]

Simple: divide the entire squad in three groups: "100% should stay", "100% should go" and "still in doubt". This according to what you think is best, not what will happen.

100% SHOULD STAY
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
22. Dani Alves
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto

DOUBTFUL
2. Montoya
7. Pedro
14. Mascherano
25. Oier
21. Adriano

I agree with all of your list except Alexis. I think he must go and with the money used to fund transfer in. All due respect to Alexis for his services of course. The Pedro in 'doubtful' column is perfect, because if you get the proper change in tactics and Pedro comes back firing it would work again for the little Canarian. Why do I say that and omit Alexis who has hit all time numbers for himself? Because we have all seen how clinical of a finisher on the biggest stages Pedro can be whereas with Alexis he finishes tap ins mostly. We are in desperate need of clinical finishers, and if the coach can do something about Pedro to bring it out of him once again, I would rather see that than have to watch the roller coaster that is Alexis with no promise of finishing.

 

[FCB_M3]

JDS should stay.

 

[Aryagorn]

100% SHOULD STAY
2. Montoya(he would be a very good back-up and would stand a chance to have a very bright future as well... so plz let him stay)
3. Piqué
6. Xavi(just for the seniority... But please put him in his place and not let him have any say in the work of the coach)
8. Iniesta
7. Pedro
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba


100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
4. Fàbregas(no need of this choker... more of an Arsenal prodigal son he is than the Barcelona one. Cash in on him please)
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
14. Mascherano
22. Dani Alves
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello

DOUBTFUL
9. Alexis
25. Oier
21. Adriano
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto