Players like Pique, Busquets , Rakitic, Vidal has never been a bad influence on anyone. Young players always talk highly of them. Will find out if Suarez was a bad effect of any young guy in Atletico soon enough.
Yes, ganging them was a mistake, but as I explained a post earlier it is due to a catastrophic job from the board with tons of bad signings. The club so far has failed to replace Iniesta and Mascherano, never mind Pique & Busquets.
At the end of the day we had to pay for our mistakes sooner or later. But casting out veterans that way, which was made solely due to covid-19 situation, could be more costly than what people think.
If we fail to make it to top 4 spot, the price we pay is way more than one trophy less year
1) They were not 'bad influence' in terms of professionalism (these names only, bcz Suarez at least might also be bad influence in this respect), but they were bad influence with their lack of effort on the pitch
2) Board did not have any plan in 'replacing' them. All those names you mentioned are not transfers resulted from any targeted planning. When i say all, I mean ALL of them. Even Coutinho, Demb, and Griez, were bought as potentially star/world-class starters but without any study where and how to play.
3) Still kicking them out was right and it should have happened earlier. When you sink with every passing day, you don't wait to hit the bottom praying that in the meantime you will be able to find replacement, you get rid of the toxic roots ASAP.
About the top-4 it's a delusion to think that with Suarez Raki and Vidal we would be cruising towards the top-4.
Chances to finish top-4 or even higher are better with Pedri, Dest, Pjanic, Braithwaite, Dembele, Griezman, Coutinho, Ansu, Minqueza, Araujo than with Messi, Suarez, Vidal, Raki, Busim Pique.
The last 3 weeks attest to that observation