footyfan
Calma, calma
Footyfan, what I don't get is that how can Messi be a worse player (my words, I think you are too polite to spell it out, you called him "different") when stats (like those posted by jiopi, taken from whoscored) suggested otherwise? Are the stats deceiving, or is the drop in Messi's game, whatever it is, be it the explosiveness, speed etc. not reflected in the stats?
Well, he's not worse per se, he's a different player, definitely not as exciting to watch though. First, let me just say, that when he has the ball, he has been better this season than last. That much is pretty evident...
However, the important stats from whoscored do support my point, here's something that I just compiled (I've only considered matches where he played the full 90 minutes for consistency):
As I said, becoming more and more a pure striker as opposed to the false 9 that he was before. His touches/game, passes/game have both gone down fairly significantly, showing less involvement in the game than before. This is partly because he is walking around with poor movement, not making space for himself to receive the pass. If you notice, he always receives the ball in the same type of situations most of the time and these are usually non-dangerous situations to the opposition.
Also, his through passes/game have gone down a lot (by 75%), along with key passes, meaning he can't find his teammates behind the defence as consistently as before.
There's a lot that's not in the stats too, things that you can only tell by watching the games. And those visual cues definitely suggest to me that he's not the same player, although he has been better this season in some aspects than last season. On the other hand, I get the feeling he's a lot more efficient with his chances, his finishing has improved a lot when you compare to him before when he would waste easy chances. He's added headers and free-kicks to his repertoire, he can hold off players in the box a lot better. That's why I say he's a different player, not a worse one.