Which forward should leave in the summer?

Which forward should leave?

  • Alexis Sanchez

    Votes: 20 48.8%
  • David Villa

    Votes: 13 31.7%
  • Cristian Tello

    Votes: 2 4.9%
  • Pedro

    Votes: 1 2.4%
  • Isaac Cuenca

    Votes: 5 12.2%
  • Gerard Deulofeu

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    41

Garrus

New member
I'm just using your logic of ' No. of goals' as a way to value a player in our squad, Isn't it obvious.
You can in fact tell me that tello is really >>> than pedro, And put me in a very tight spot, PAWN me as they like to call it on the internet, But you can't admit such a thing can you.
 

Paganinisrvnge

New member
I don't want to be rude but I can't understand how any of you could want Tello or Cuenca, 2 very promising young players from the youth system, to leave over Alexis.
 

Semi-Neutral

Sir Alupp Heynrguson
Alexis misses tons of easy chances, dives, isn't all too useful on offense. His workrate is good and he had a nice goal against Getafe, but other than that nothing really. Tello isn't too good at tracking back, I'll give you that, but he has got mad pace and is a quite dangerous dribbler, don't know why you would say he's one-dimensional. Additionally, he's got a nice right foot and isn't afraid of cracking a shot. I guess it depends on what you want in your players, a more defensive winger who helps back and still gets occasional goals or a pacy, aggressive winger who gets quite a few goals considering his minutes. Either way, it's certainly not a "no-brainer" which one is better.
 

Garrus

New member
I don't want to be rude but I can't understand how any of you could want Tello or Cuenca, 2 very promising young players from the youth system, to leave over Alexis.
Cuenca is definitely a promising player, As for tello....things are more blurry.

Alexis misses tons of easy chances, dives, isn't all too useful on offense. His workrate is good and he had a nice goal against Getafe, but other than that nothing really. Tello isn't too good at tracking back, I'll give you that, but he has got mad pace and is a quite dangerous dribbler, don't know why you would say he's one-dimensional. Additionally, he's got a nice right foot and isn't afraid of cracking a shot. I guess it depends on what you want in your players, a more defensive winger who helps back and still gets occasional goals or a pacy, aggressive winger who gets quite a few goals considering his minutes. Either way, it's certainly not a "no-brainer" which one is better.
An interesting theoretical talk, How about we put it in an actual practical situation, Shall we.
Suppose we have a tough champion league game coming up, With Bayern or juventus, Pedro isn't available, And You have to choose between alexis or tello, Which one would you pick?.
Now that's what i call a -no brainier-, Even with his dives and missing tons of chances as you like to call it, And tello's dangerous dribbles and nice right foot, You would pick sanchez over him, In fact that'll be the choice of anyone who his sole purpose isn't to see us sinking ourselves in deep shit in that particular game.
Even if we supposed that tito sees great potential in tello in the future, He can't let alexis go just yet, Until tello prove that he'll be reliable for these kind of situations, Which currently he's isn't even near, But i can be wrong, Who knows.

In my case it's because I believe that Alexis has the potential to be better
+1
 

DonAndres

Wild Man of Borneo
I'm just using your logic of ' No. of goals' as a way to value a player in our squad, Isn't it obvious.
You can in fact tell me that tello is really >>> than pedro, And put me in a very tight spot, PAWN me as they like to call it on the internet, But you can't admit such a thing can you.

Its not just goals. Tello is insanely fast, tricky, an adept dribbler, and has a great shot. He is somewhat one dimensional and not creative but it's not like his playing style requires him to be. All Alexis has is a good workrate and stamina but nothing else. Tello provides something different to the squad. He gives a different style of play when the rest of our offense is lacking and unmotivated. Alexis doesn't really provide anything special or new and isn't great coming off the bench or as a starter.
 

Semi-Neutral

Sir Alupp Heynrguson
Suppose we have a tough champion league game coming up, With Bayern or juventus, Pedro isn't available, And You have to choose between alexis or tello, Which one would you pick?.

Alexis simply because we need the defensive cover with Alves constantly bombing forward and Bayern and Juventus both being an extremely dangerous offensive threat. However, when Montoya matures (who seems to be much more defensive) I would pick Tello in a heartbeat.
 

Paganinisrvnge

New member
Alexis is 3 months away from finishing his 2nd full season at Barcelona and he has shown nothing besides a couple very small glimpses of being pretty good. Unless he does something particularly special to help the team; I don't see him staying past this summer. At least I don't see the point in him staying aside from stealing minutes from Cuenca/Tello/Deulofeu.
 

Garrus

New member
Its not just goals. Tello is insanely fast, tricky, an adept dribbler, and has a great shot. He is somewhat one dimensional and not creative but it's not like his playing style requires him to be. All Alexis has is a good workrate and stamina but nothing else. Tello provides something different to the squad. He gives a different style of play when the rest of our offense is lacking and unmotivated. Alexis doesn't really provide anything special or new and isn't great coming off the bench or as a starter.
"insanely fast, tricky, an adept dribbler, and has a great shot" all fall under the heading of 'Goals', Am i right, What you want add is, Off the ball movements, Creating spaces and tracking back, Which are all near zero for tello, And all of these are a 'Must' present qualities in our wingers, These aren't optional luxurious bonuses, That's just how our system works.
The only reason why we aren't seeing the negative outcomes of these shortcomings of tello is because tito doesn't let him play much, And thank god for that.

Alexis simply because we need the defensive cover with Alves constantly bombing forward and Bayern and Juventus both being an extremely dangerous offensive threat. However, when Montoya matures (who seems to be much more defensive) I would pick Tello in a heartbeat.
You can apply this to any team , Nothing particular about these two.
But now that we're at it, Tello...dangerous offensive team, mmmm that does seem to ring a bell, oh yeah it's one with real madrid, Well that worked out splendidly, And as i remember his defensive shortcomings weren't standing out actually, Because he was horrendous in pretty much everything else, In his defense, He did seem to bore arbeloa to the death with the same trick, I'll give him that.
 

Semi-Neutral

Sir Alupp Heynrguson
Do you really want to go with examples of bad games by these players? Sanchez has had some awful performances quite regularly, whereas that is the only real bad performance by Tello, and it was against Madrid when Tello was quite young.
 

footyfan

Calma, calma
@no80s: We don't need hardworking defensive wingers on both sides.

I would keep Alexis over Tello because he is more talented and his problems are mental more than anything else.
 

Paganinisrvnge

New member
Why is Alexis getting so much patience? Screw that. Sell him if he doesn't show something worthwhile in the next 3 months. The club can't afford to keep giving him chances to come good for a 3rd season.
 

DonAndres

Wild Man of Borneo
"insanely fast, tricky, an adept dribbler, and has a great shot" all fall under the heading of 'Goals', Am i right, What you want add is, Off the ball movements, Creating spaces and tracking back, Which are all near zero for tello, And all of these are a 'Must' present qualities in our wingers, These aren't optional luxurious bonuses, That's just how our system works.
The only reason why we aren't seeing the negative outcomes of these shortcomings of tello is because tito doesn't let him play much, And thank god for that.

He isn't horrible off the ball. He just doesn't have an overhyped reputation for that sort of thing like Alexis does (seriously i rarely see him do anything special in terms of dragging defenders away from the middle). Tello stretches the play very well as a winger and the defenders are weary of his speed so they do follow him when he makes bombing off the ball runs. That's basicaly what it is to create space and help with off the ball movements. The only thing Alexis actually has over Tello is defensive workrate. And considering he is nearly useless in attack, I wouldn't play him for his tracking back. Granted, Tello may not be great when played as a starter, but he definitely is a better overall player than Alexis.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top