11 - Neymar Jr. - v4

Status
Not open for further replies.
G

Gasgas

Guest
Neymar is good, but people will need to find a better argument than 30 Goals scored in a Season in total.
Why?
= because these are different times than 1994, 1998 and 2002, and comparing 30 Goals scored today with 30 Goals scored back then are misleading

1. La Liga wasn different, and Barca and Real weren't as rich as today. In the past, Italian clubs were extremely rich (during 90ies and in early 2000s)
-- so, in those years, Barca and Real didn't have the money to buy expensive players as today, and thus the difference between Barca&Real and the rest of the league was much smaller
-- that means that in the past La Liga was not a 2-horse-race, but a more difficult championship, and it was much harder to win against any weaker opponent than today
-- in number, just an example (and these are NOT the real numbers, but my estimation)
-- imagine that in 90's:
-- Barca and Real had 20 Millions to spend on transfers each Season
-- and an average La liga team had 5 Millions to spend

-- today:
-- Barca and Real have 100 Millions to spend each Season
-- and an average La liga team has 10 Millions to spend

-- so, you see, the difference (just an example again) went from 4:1 to 10:1
-- this is why Barca and Real are today statpading against most of the opponents with silly 6:0 and 8:0 wins
-- and this is why Barca and Real are lately having Seasons with 90, 95 or 100 points
-- and this is why both Barca and Real are scoring an insane number of Goals in La liga (and in Cup) lately, compared to the past times
-- also, this means that current Barca's and Real's attackers will score much more goals than their attackers from 1994, 1998 or 2002, and that was fans may be mislead with that fact and they may thought: "Oh, the current players are a few levels above all those players from 10-15 years ago".
-- well only Messi is better. Even CR7 would struggle in 1998'
2. the 2nd reason is, that until a few years ago, Barca and Real were allowed to have only 3 players from outside the EU
-- even when Rijkaard came, we needed to "count" how many foreigners we have and we had to decide whom we will and whom we won't buy
-- all (or most of the) Brasilians, Argentines, Uruguayans were all foreigners=back then
-- but also, all players from Croatia (like Rakitic and Modric) were outside of European union back then and they were considered as foreigners

Just look at the current team:
1. Bravo, Chile=a foreigner
2. Masch, Argentina=a foreigner
3. Messi, Argentina=a foreigner
4. Neymar, Brasil=a foreigner
5. Rafinha, Brasil=a foreigner
6. Suarez, Uruguay=a foreigner
7. Rakitic, Croatia=a foreigner
8. Alves, Brasil=a foreigner
9. Douglas, Brasil=a foreigner
10. Adriano, Brasil=a foreigner

And now, look at number of foreigners in our team in 1996, for example:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1995–96_FC_Barcelona_season
-- so, you see, we needed to have almost ALL players from Spain
-- so, when you can have only Spanish players, of course that your team will be much weaker compared to average La liga teams than when you can have 10 Brasilians and Argentines

In late 90's and early 2000's, we started to buy some EU players because they were not foreigners and we started to get a dual citizenship to some Brasilians, so we started to have a few EU players and 4-5 Brasil/Argentian guys in our team, like in 2001-2002-2003:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001–02_FC_Barcelona_season
-- here we have 5 guys from South America, and probably 2 of them had a Spanish citizenship, so they were allowed to play
-- so, as you see, Barca and Real is 90's:
= were both not that rich + we were not allowed to have more than 3 foreigners
-- then in early 2000's:
= we still weren't nowhere as rich as today + we now had more foreigners
-- while today:
= we are filthy rich and we have a 2-horse-La Liga-race + we can have virtually as many foreigners as we want with new dual citizenship and European union rules

That is an answer why current Barca's and Real's players will have much better stats that Fcs from 90's, early 2000's or from 2005.

To show you even more stats, this is the number of victories per Season for Barca's teams in the last 20 years:
1994, 25 wins out of 38 matches (The Dream team from Cruijff)
1995: 18 wins in 38 matches, lol
1996: 22 wins in 42 matches, lol
1997, 28 wins in 42 matches
1998: 23 wins in 38 matches, 74 points
1999: 24 wins in 38 matches, 79 points
2000: 19 wins in 38 matches, 64 points, lol
2001: 17 wins in 38 matches, 63 points, lol
2002: 18 wins in 38 matches, 64 points, lol
2003, 15 wins in 38 matches, 56 points, lol
2004: 21 wins in 38 matches, 72 points
2005: 25 wins in 38 matches, 84 points, Champions again
2006: 25 wins in 38 matches, 82 Points, Champions again, Champions league winners
2007: 22 wins in 38 matches, 76 Points
2008: 19 wins in 38 matches, 76 points
2009: 27 wins in 38 matches, 87 Points, Pep, Champions
2010: 31 wins in 38 matches, 99 Points, lol
2011: 30 wins in 38 matches, 98 Points, lol
2012: 28 wins in 38 matches, 91 Points
2013: 32 wins in 38 matches, 100 Points, Tito
2014: 27 wins in 38 matches, 87 Points, Tata

Goals for Barca:
1994: 91 goals in 38 matches (Romario 30 Goals)
1995: 60 goals in 38 matches, lol (Jordi Cruijff 9, Koeman 9, Stiochkov 9)
1996: 72 goals in 42 matches (Oscar Garcia 10, Kodro 9)
1997: 102 goals in 42 matches (Ronaldo 34 Goals)
1998: 78 Goals in 38 matches (Rivaldo 19, Luis Enrique 18)
1999: 87 Goals in 38 matches (Rivaldo 24, Kluivert 15)
2000: 70 Goals in 38 matches (Kluivert 15)
2001: 80 Goals in 38 matches (Rivaldo 23, Kluivert 18)
2002: 65 Goals in 38 matches (Kluivert 18, Saviola 17)
2003: 63 Goals in 38 matches (Kluivert 16)
2004: 63 Goals in 38 matches (Ronaldinho 14, Saviola 14), LOL
2005: 73 Goals in 38 matches (Etoo 25, Guily 11, Ronaldinho 9), LOL, Champions
2006: 80 Goals in 38 matches (Etoo 26, Ronaldinho 17, Larsson 10), Champions league winners, LOL
2007: 78 Goals in 38 matches (Ronaldinho 21, Messi 14, Etoo 11)
2008: 76 Goals in 38 matches (Etoo 16, Henry 12, Messi 10, Krkic 10, Ronaldinho 8)
2009: 105 Goals in 38 matches (Etoo 30, Messi 23, Henry 19)
2010: 98 Goals in 38 matches (Messi 34, Ibra 16, Pedro 12)
2011: 95 Goals in 38 matches (Messi 31, Villa 18, Pedro 13)
2012: 114 Goals in 38 matches (Real 121 Goals, lol) (Messi 50, Alexis 11, Xavi 10, Fab 9
2013: 115 Goals in 38 matches (LOLOLOLOLOLOLO) (Messi 46, Fab 11, Villa 10, Sanchez 8, Pedro 7, Tello 7)
2014: 100 Goals in 38 matches (Messi 28, Alexis 19, Pedro 15, Neymar 9, Fab 8)

-- so, it is insane to compare the current Goals and stats with stats from 1994, 1998 or 2002.
-- La liga has became a statpading contest for Barca and Real
-- the same is with opponents in cup
-- CL again, smaller teams can't make surprises like 10 or 20 years ago
= in all competitions the influx of money has caused much larger differences between top sides and average sides, and thus, goals and stats from players from Barca and Real have inflated too much

I mean, Barca's best league scorers in Seasons 95 and 96 scored 9 and 10 Goals.
Brasilian Ronaldo scored 34 Goals in 1997. If he played in the current era (where Cristiano manages to score 40-50 La liga Goals), then Brasilian Ronaldo would score 50-60 Goals per Season, lol.
Also, Ronaldinho scored 14 and 9 Goals in 2004 and 2005 in first 2 Seasons where we finished 2nd and the 1st.
So, according to those numbers, Neymar currently looks as twice as good player as Ronaldinho from his first 2 Seasons, lol.

So, saying that Ney is awesome is one thing.
But saying that he is better than (phenomenal) players from prior eras is just waaaaay off.

Again guys, if CR7 scores that many goals today, and Romario, Stoichkov, Brasilian Ronaldo and Rivaldo never came even close.
Don't you think that something is wrong with the current stats?
Rivaldo never scored more than 24 Goals.
And seriously, Rivaldo was a few levels better player than CR7 in all aspects of the game.
I guess i have to get used to this BBZ not the neymar-loving i hoped for
:banghead: :facepalm:
 

mark1nhu

New member
BBZ,

He is not talking about La Liga only.

30 goals in a season (not finished yet) IS a very good achievement in all different countries around the globe.

We are just used to insane numbers from Messi and Cristina that we forgot about it.
 

EdmondDantes

New member
His performances are picking up again after that little blip which thankfully coincided with Suarez's ascendancy. It's tough for all three to have great games all at once or else we would be winning every game 9-0...

30 goals and 9 assists so far, big game player too.
 

StarLord

New member
@BBZ8800

So kind of you to calculate those statistics.

But it would be instructive if you did the same with the EPL/Serie A/Bundesliga as well.

It is not just La Liga that is oligopolistic, but all the major leagues.



Edit: And having said that La Liga is a two-horse race (not really during the past 2 years or so) that league at least involves a "race". Other major Euro-leagues are done before they even begin, all of them basically.
 
Last edited:

mark1nhu

New member
@BBZ8800

So kind of you to calculate those statistics.

But it would be instructive if you did the same with the EPL/Serie A/Bundesliga as well.

It is not just La Liga that is oligopolistic, but all the major leagues.

Yes.

Please do it for us! Do it buddy!
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
The argument that it is easier to score in La Liga today applies to everyone then, Messi included.

If it is so easy to score today then why had no other attacking player at Barca bar Messi met those figures?

Neymar plays wide and is on next to no set pieces penalties. To score 30 goals is phenomenal and more than anyone in recent years played as a wide player at Barca bar the GOAT.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
BBZ by your standards we should not compare Messi's goal tally to those of the past either?

The different logic you use to down play Neymar is unreal

If you don't want to compare Neymars goals to players on 2002 that's fine. Compate it to every other Barca player bar Messi since 2002 and none have the goals Neymar does.
 

StarLord

New member
The argument that it is easier to score in La Liga today applies to everyone then, Messi included.

If it is so easy to score today then why had no other attacking player at Barca bar Messi met those figures?

Neymar plays wide and is on next to no set pieces penalties. To score 30 goals is phenomenal and more than anyone in recent years played as a wide player at Barca bar the GOAT.

Henry/Ibra/Villa/Pedro/Alexis could never do what the young Brazilian is currently doing this season. Neymar can very easily surpass Eto'o's great 08/09 season but playing out wide and taking no penaldos/set pieces!!! Simply astonishing!

And Neymar is doing anything but statpadding. Out of his 6 CL goals, 5 were scored against PSG (!) The strongest team we have met in Europe this season. He did not score against Apoel or some shit like that. He also scored the opener vs Ajax.

- He has also scored vs Real Madrid (a)

- Scored twice vs Atletico (a) in the Copa

- Scored against Sevilla (a)

- Scored against Atletico at home in the league, the opener no less.

- Scored against Villarreal in both the league and the Cup.

- Twice opened the scoring vs PSG.

- Two crucial late goals vs Bilbao.


And lots of other great things that I am too lazy to recollect right now.
 

StarLord

New member
BBZ by your standards we should not compare Messi's goal tally to those of the past either?

The different logic you use to down play Neymar is unreal

If you don't want to compare Neymars goals to players on 2002 that's fine. Compate it to every other Barca player bar Messi since 2002 and none have the goals Neymar does.

What about Christina's goals? How much do they count? Or Aguero's for example, who has been scoring at a far higher rate in the mighty EPL, than in the poor two-horse race La Liga.

But no, we should only apply the time-filter that BBZ has discovered to Neymar!
 

BBZ8800

Senior Member
BBZ,

He is not talking about La Liga only.

30 goals in a season (not finished yet) IS a very good achievement in all different countries around the globe.

We are just used to insane numbers from Messi and Cristina that we forgot about it.

I wasn't saying in my post that he is not good, now I have said that anywhere in this new topic.

But there is a difference between scoring XX goals TODAY in be one of 4-5 best players in the world.
And comparing current stats from any player with stats from 90's or 2000's.

Ney has 18 league Goals this Season.He will end the Season with 20-24.
More Goals than Ronaldinho ever scored, and Ronaldinho was taking both free kicks and penalty kicks. (ok, not all penalty kicks)

If CR7 scored more Goals that Brasilian Ronaldo, Romario, Rivaldo and Ronaldinho, does that mean that CR7 is a better player or a better finisher than them?
= imo, he isn't better than any of these Brasilians

Also, if Ney is in this Season scoring more Goals than Ronaldinho ever did for Barca (overall goals, but even in a League matches), that should imply that Ney is already on the higher level than Ronaldinho from his prime, and that doesn't make any sense.
Also, current Neymar is already (according to numbers) on the same level as Rivaldo on his prime.

So, my point of that post is: please, don't compare 1994 or 1998 with the current statpading La liga stats, where CR7 looks liks a godlike player and like a 2nd best player who ever walked on Earth :facepalm:

I respect CR7, but that is just rude towards Rivaldo, Ronaldinho, Brasilian Ronaldo etc.
 
L

linetty

Guest
Those discussions.... Neymar scored 30 and assisted 9. These are outstanding numbers that only few players are capable of achieving. END OF.
 

StarLord

New member
Those discussions.... Neymar scored 30 and assisted 9. These are outstanding numbers that only few players are capable of achieving. END OF.

The point that the defenders of Neymar are trying to make, is that his contribution is even more important than his -as you said- outstanding numbers would suggest.

He has scored in multiple big games, multiple openers, very little binge scoring against already destroyed opponents, and he also plays out wide.
 

Devils

Senior Member
THE big game player. Same can be said for Suarez too.

We are so lucky, in the past few season if Messi had a game like he did yesterday, we would have been fucked in the attacking department. Thank god for Neymar.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Home of Barca Fans

Top