24 - Thomas Vermaelen

DonAndres

Wild Man of Borneo
I don't think some people here really understand how collective defending really works with the knee-jerk name dropping and extreme over-dependence on reputation. I'm not saying Vermaelen is even a good signing because there are a ton of obstacles he has to overcome before I'll ever be *happy* with him here. It's just that a good portion of the complaints here are for all the wrong reasons and birth a mentality that can only be satisfied by 100% unrealistic demands. Ultimately what it does is imply that Vermaelen cannot and will not succeed unless his name is Benatia or Hummels or whatever other flashy big name that'll be thrown around.

There are some very legitimate doubts here which I also share, but some are just downright irrational.
 

D10S_JC

Member
barcastuff: New Barcelona centre back Thomas Vermaelen, who is recovering from a thigh injury, won't be fit to play until mid-September. [sport]
 

Cule4life

The Culest
I don't think some people here really understand how collective defending really works with the knee-jerk name dropping and extreme over-dependence on reputation. I'm not saying Vermaelen is even a good signing because there are a ton of obstacles he has to overcome before I'll ever be *happy* with him here. It's just that a good portion of the complaints here are for all the wrong reasons and birth a mentality that can only be satisfied by 100% unrealistic demands. Ultimately what it does is imply that Vermaelen cannot and will not succeed unless his name is Benatia or Hummels or whatever other flashy big name that'll be thrown around.

There are some very legitimate doubts here which I also share, but some are just downright irrational.

barcastuff: New Barcelona centre back Thomas Vermaelen, who is recovering from a thigh injury, won't be fit to play until mid-September. [sport]

.........
 

Professor Chaos

New member
barcastuff: New Barcelona centre back Thomas Vermaelen, who is recovering from a thigh injury, won't be fit to play until mid-September. [sport]
nicolascageconfusedemotions.gif
 

DonAndres

Wild Man of Borneo
.........

One of the legitimate concerns manifests itself :lol:

Again, I never said that we should be automatically satisfied with his transfer. It's just that he doesn't need to be a 'world class CB' to perform well, just some consistent fitness and a return to form. That enough should be fine for the role he's probably going to play, defending is a collective effort and a big difference isn't made by the inclusion of a marquee individual.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top