Arturo Vidal

JohnN

Senior Member
Then educate yourself more.
You can't make such conclusions with such limited exposure on the player

Vidal has been worldclass for quite something years for Leverkusen, Juventus, Bayern and Chile NT

And now is in his final washed up years at Barca

You shouldn't be so strict with others but let's move on.
The point was about Barcelona and not other clubs.
So, for Barcelona, he was never a better player. I don't care about previous clubs. I see the kind of player Vidal has been, and he would never fit us, not even at his best. Rakitic has also been world class for Sevilla and Croatia, but I don't care about that.
 

devo901

New member
who ever says Puig is ready has to convince me... to me another unexperienced player, who on top of it - is physically not ready... like Fati who is being tossed on the field....
 

mc_lovin

Senior Member
I would rather see Puig than a Busquets-Rakitic-Vidal midfield.

I have no idea what you see in Vidal, hes a nothing player.
 

Nazario1985

Senior Member
I would rather see Puig than a Busquets-Rakitic-Vidal midfield.

I have no idea what you see in Vidal, hes a nothing player.

When you say i would rather do you mean i would rather lose everything just to experience something exotic i'm thinking of ?

Puig is not ready to be a starter !
 

mc_lovin

Senior Member
When you say i would rather do you mean i would rather lose everything just to experience something exotic i'm thinking of ?

Puig is not ready to be a starter !


Hes not, but neither is Vidal. The one thing he has going for him are his goal contributions, but apart from that hes atrocious - he has no presence in midfield at all.

I dont know if Busquets/Rakitic/Puig or Busquets/Rakitic/Vidal looks worse, but with Puig theres at least some technical quality in there. Both lineups wont be the reason we win things.
 

Nazario1985

Senior Member
Most sucess tackles of the last decade
hihi2-2020-01-01_07-26-45_957524-640x640.jpg
 

RevoTeller

New member
Only a fool would sell someone like Vidal in the January transfer window.
Especially if the team selling him is Barcelona, a squad known to be full of dynamic midfielders who press and run a lot, LOL. :lol:

Let's go and face once again the CL with the stupendous

Roberto-Busquets-Rakitic

midfield.

LMAO. :lol:
 

Porque

Senior Member
Only a fool would sell someone like Vidal in the January transfer window.
Especially if the team selling him is Barcelona, a squad known to be full of dynamic midfielders who press and run a lot, LOL. :lol:

Let's go and face once again the CL with the stupendous

Roberto-Busquets-Rakitic

midfield.

LMAO. :lol:

This. Who is replacing Vidal's experience and instant impact as a sub for the second half of the season if Vidal goes. Puig is not that type of player and is replacing Alena if anyone. Or do we go back in for the Chinese Dragon for half a season.

Only deal that makes sense off the top of my head is Eriksen for Vidal (+Raki going in the summer). If it is Olmo then we are dead.
 

mc_lovin

Senior Member
Only a fool would sell someone like Vidal in the January transfer window.
Especially if the team selling him is Barcelona, a squad known to be full of dynamic midfielders who press and run a lot, LOL. :lol:

Let's go and face once again the CL with the stupendous

Roberto-Busquets-Rakitic

midfield.

LMAO. :lol:


Not that Rakitic-Busquets-Vidal is a sight to behold. And I wouldnt call him dynamic, or intense, or whatever. He looks as washed up as Rakitic. One of them gone is a win in my book if replaced - even with someone like Olmo.
 

weloveyuner

Member
What is with all the hate for Vidal? Is he Xavi? No. Is he Iniesta? No. But that doesn't mean he isn't a good player. He provides the muscle and rough tackles we need. De Jong and Rakitic sure as hell aren't going to provide them.
 

Barcilliant

Senior Member
What is with all the hate for Vidal? Is he Xavi? No. Is he Iniesta? No. But that doesn't mean he isn't a good player. He provides the muscle and rough tackles we need. De Jong and Rakitic sure as hell aren't going to provide them.

Exactly. All these youngsters like Puig, Arthur and De Jong are pretty soft. Vidal is not a perfect fit for Barca but he brings something different.

He has actually brought alot as an impact sub when we are struggling. Alot of opposition players are actually wary of him especially Real Madrid 😂
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top