Late in the 2018 season, it was common knowledge within that club that Villa would be leaving for Japan at the end of the season to finish his career overseas. It was a much-needed glimmer of hope for Badillo. In early October, she found herself seated on a countertop in the training center when Villa entered.
“David came up to me and sat next to me,” says Badillo, “but so close that our thighs were touching. And so I, being so close, thought ‘how do I minimize this without making this a thing.’ I scooted over a couple of inches, and then he scooted over so our legs were almost touching. At that point I gave up and was like ‘I’m just going to give up, i’ll just let it go.’ He was just watching videos on his phone, asking me if I liked dancing.”
Eventually, one of the other interns approached and touched Villa’s arm to get his attention. Villa responded “don’t touch me,” shooing the intern away.
“And I was like ‘hey, how bout we don’t touch me either, then?’” says Badillo. “And then he turned to me and told me that he’d never touched me.”
Badillo retreated to a storage closet to compose herself. Moments later, she received a text message from another staff member, a photo of her and Villa seated on the countertop just moments earlier with a drawing of a heart superimposed around the two.
Badillo showed her supervisor, Melvyn Pamplona, the image. Pamplona, as Badillo remembers it, burst out laughing. Later, as the two sat and ate lunch together, Pamplona told Badillo to get her phone back out, insisting that she show others at the table the image. By the time it made it back to Christen, the head trainer, it was accompanied by a caption: “new office romance.”
After the incident on the training table and Badillo’s visible discomfort with it, Kevin Christen asked to speak with Badillo when she arrived at work two days later. They met privately in Christen’s office with no HR representative present.
“(Our meeting) basically went to the tune of ‘hey, all this terrible stuff has happened and there’s not really a lot we can do about it, so how bout you don’t sit on the side of the counter where you usually do,’” Badillo says. “Kevin wanted me to stay over by him, so that maybe David would come find me less, and I also wasn’t supposed to treat David anymore — I really liked that idea.”
(...)
Kevin Christen left the club in early 2020, months before Badillo went public with her accusations against Villa. But Melvyn Pamplona still works at NYCFC. In its statement, the club said that it had “taken corrective action with respect to the one employee that remains” with the organization. The club declined to name the employee or elaborate specifically on what action was taken. They also declined to elaborate on what measures, specifically, were taken (if any) in regards to Pamplona.