The theory is that he missed that prolific striker who could pull out some goals from nothing to get through the "unlucky". Put a false 9 in place of Benzuma at Madrid over the two legs versus Chelsea and City and they would have been out.
If the final piece in the puzzle can't give Pep that margin then it will never happen.
This theory is so flawed...
First of all, Erling usually scores tap-ins and oneVones rather than specials 'out of nothing' goals
Then, remove one cog from the wheel of total control and domination that City are, and you have less control and less domination.
Sure enough domination still to beat the shit out of the likes of Burnleys, Aston Villas, Leicesters, Evertons and the like in EPL
but maybe less than enough to do so against the best teams in Europe like Liverpool Chelsea Bayern and others
This means that dear Erling will pad his stats against the common EPL fodder, and will be mister invisible in the difficult CL knockouts or the derbys of EPL
Actually, this transfer is so shockingly against the way Pep changed City since 2020 (towards less attack and more control), that I am really doubting he took the decision in a sane mind.
Compare him to Kane - the target of last summer- and its day and night.
Kane would fit like a glove into Pep's logic of more control, as he drops back and plays like one of the greatest 10s in the sport