Oh well, here I go again down memory lane.
The best version of Pique was that young dude from early 2009 right until Shakira appeared in the picture. From then on Pique gradually went back (I wouldn't say declined) to the common level of great defenders. He is still fantastic, but I really miss the LEGEND this man was during 2009-2011 period. Besides the defensive awareness most of the folks here will remember Pique moving (I'd say "jump") straight from CB to CF position, not because Barca were one goal down in the result, but simply to fuck with the opposition. It was crazy, hilarious and at times brilliant tactic. The comparisons with Franz Beckenbauer (the Piquenbauer) were probably spot on, I can't tell, I've never seen the German legend play.