Hummels or Kompany

[mixer]

Luiz is the better player! simple!

Luiz isn't even half as good as Hummels or Kompany is.

 

[kingleo]

Luiz isn't even half as good as Hummels or Kompany is.

Luiz is definitely better! he has toned down the crazy side of his game now and he is much better now! if a defender will ever win a Ballon d'or again it will most likely be him!

 

[Puyol the wall]

Luiz is definitely better! he has toned down the crazy side of his game now and he is much better now! if a defender will ever win a Ballon d'or again it will most likely be him!

Hummels is fast becoming one of the best defenders there is and as for Luiz he still remains Luizaster.

 

[Aryagorn]

Hummels is fast becoming one of the best defenders there is and as for Luiz he still remains Luizaster.

yeah. Luizaster for the attackers advancing towards him

 

[La Furia]

For Barca, Hummels is probably the better investment, younger and marginally cheaper. He can still get better, though a Hummels-Pique partnership lacks leadership.

Right now Kompany is easily the better player though, considering Kompany is close to being the best CB in the world.

 

[mixer]

Luiz is definitely better! he has toned down the crazy side of his game now and he is much better now! if a defender will ever win a Ballon d'or again it will most likely be him!

So you are insinuating that Luiz is at the same level as Cannavaro was?

btw I would prefer even a chinese midget than Luiz.

Hummels is 10 times better than this brazilian monkey.

 

[Cruijffista]

I vote Javi Martinez. I think he's a perfect fit for our system.

He has the size and speed Barca needs in that CB position. I couldn't have been more impressed with him against Manchester United in the EL.

 

[RedMadridista]

For Barca, Hummels is probably the better investment, younger and marginally cheaper. He can still get better, though a Hummels-Pique partnership lacks leadership.

Right now Kompany is easily the better player though, considering Kompany is close to being the best CB in the world.

Who is better?

 

[barcelonista]

Who is better?

 

[Puyol the wall]

 

[UEFA_Barça_Chris]

 

[kingleo]

So you are insinuating that Luiz is at the same level as Cannavaro was?

btw I would prefer even a chinese midget than Luiz.

Hummels is 10 times better than this brazilian monkey.

err no im not! i said if a defender ever wins a Ballon D'or again i think Luiz has the capabilities to reach that level. and he would be the most likely to win it imo.

And no im sorry to tell you this but Hummels isn't 10 times better than Luiz sorry.

 

[Ender]

err no im not! i said if a defender ever wins a Ballon D'or again i think Luiz has the capabilities to reach that level. and he would be the most likely to win it imo.

 

[Puyol the wall]

err no im not! i said if a defender ever wins a Ballon D'or again i think Luiz has the capabilities to reach that level. and he would be the most likely to win it imo.

And no im sorry to tell you this but Hummels isn't 10 times better than Luiz sorry.

Luizaster y u try to win ballon do'r at the expense of ur chelsea

 

[AnfieldEd]

For Barca, Hummels is probably the better investment, younger and marginally cheaper. He can still get better, though a Hummels-Pique partnership lacks leadership.

Right now Kompany is easily the better player though, considering Kompany is close to being the best CB in the world.

I think that sums it up quite nicely and I agree with this.