So did he have a strong case because of his performances, or because he had a band around his arm?
He got dropped at RM ffs. And it wasn't some lunatic decision. He has had a below-par 2012-13 season. There were a lot of Spanish players who were more important for Spain during the Euros. And for Real Madrid last season too. Cristiano, Ozil, Di Maria, Pepe, Ramos, Alonso.
He got dropped for political/personal reasons, let's not ignore that point! And it's a stupid decision.
Let's not play down his importance at Euro 2012, important saves in the group stages against Croatia and Italy, one from Motta was excellent. Key penalty save against Portugal. In the final at 2-0, he made an excellent block from Di Natale, that goes in and it could have changed things.
As Adil mentioned he was was a key player for Spain and Real Madrid last season. Watched nearly all of Real's game's last season and can safely say he was more important than Alonso, Di Maria and Pepe. Di Maria started 16 games in La Liga and of the nine games that Pepe missed three had clean sheets(13 in total last season)
As for this season, I don't think Casillas has been poor at all. They've only conceded 1 goal more than Barcelona, has Valdes had a very poor season then? After 18 games last season, they had let in
two less goals, not much difference especially when you take into account Adan has started the last two games and Real had shipped 6 goals. Yes Casillas came in, but it was Adan's mistake for pen and red card.
The problem for Real has been going forward, they scored 65 goals after 18 games last year, this season it's 45 a massive drop. Maybe it's the lack of penalties this season.
Casillas importance and performances are being underrated by yourself.