He's getting old, should start looking to replace him.
Yes he must be a beast he is wearing the Barca jersey i dont even care to comment on the guy anymore, not his fault he got bought by Barcas excellent scouting systemPlayed like a Tank. Slow and ....slow! You know your defense is a joke when you call someone like Mathieu "Monster" and "Beast" in the club's forum.
His distribution is piss poor, Lucho should tell him to play it short and simple.
He really was ok today - not sure what game you were watching. He takes care of his defensive duties well and provided today some important blocks. He's not the most talented in attack, but people have been getting on Alves' and Pique's back for not concentrating on defense so let's be consistent with our standards.