John Stones

opjeoff

New member
Surely for the price they paid he should already have these traits.

It really is incredible the amount of money being spent there on mediocre players.

very true, but honestly that is how rich the EPL is, they can buy mediocre players for this type of money. I'm glad we didnt buy him and brought Umtiti who is better than Stones.
 

Adversus

New member
I think Koeman is turning us into a bit of hoof ball team so I doubt Stones suits Koeman's style. Williams is far more suitable. I think Stones will be a star under Pep and he should be grateful Everton held him back from signing for Chelsea last season as Pep's style will suit him far more.

That said it's definitely not guaranteed he will go on a be that star and this transfer basically offloads the risk on to City of him turning out to be not that good after all.
 
Last edited:

Zincubus

Banned
Will be interesting to see if Pep can make a man of him. He obviously has most of the traits Pep looks for in a defender, but he was just so astoundingly bad at actual defending on so many occasions last season.

Pep was talking in glowing terms about John Stones today , there talk about him coaching Stones into a sweeper ...- Blast from the past :)

Didn't Pep do wonderful things for Pique's game ?
 

Zincubus

Banned
I think Koeman is turning us into a bit of hoof ball team so I doubt Stones suits Koeman's style. Williams is far more suitable. I think Stones will be a star under Pep and he should be grateful Everton held him back from signing for Chelsea last season as Pep's style will suit him far more.

That said it's definitely not guaranteed he will go on a be that star and this transfer basically offloads the risk on to City of him turning out to be not that good after all.

Jesus if you think Stones makes mistakes just wait till you've sat through a few games of Ashly Williams !!
 

Zincubus

Banned
very true, but honestly that is how rich the EPL is, they can buy mediocre players for this type of money. I'm glad we didnt buy him and brought Umtiti who is better than Stones.

You can't judge him as mediocre as he's only a kid who's been playing in a shockingly bad Everton team whose defence where under pressure most of the time .He will be a different player when he's not doing as much defending.

I think he'll be a better player than both Pique and Rio Ferdinand tbh
 

DonAK

President of FC Barcelona
You can't judge him as mediocre as he's only a kid who's been playing in a shockingly bad Everton team whose defence where under pressure most of the time .He will be a different player when he's not doing as much defending.

I think he'll be a better player than both Pique and Rio Ferdinand tbh

So a defender will be better when he doesn't have to............defend?

Most of his blunders were not when he was under pressure actually. He got a loooooooong way to go before even getting compared to Rio Ferdinand. Let alone surpass him. Pique's in another dimension too compared to Stones.
 

BenRobbins

New member
Same age Rio won englands player of the world cup in 02 and led leeds to a champions league semi-final along side fucking lucas radebe.

Meanwhile Stones can't get ahead of bloody Chris Smalling and Gary Cahill and is too busy falling over every 5 mins in the league.

If he wins even a tenth of what pique has then he has had a good career.
 

Nucky

Senior Member
Same age Rio won englands player of the world cup in 02 and led leeds to a champions league semi-final along side fucking lucas radebe.

Meanwhile Stones can't get ahead of bloody Chris Smalling and Gary Cahill and is too busy falling over every 5 mins in the league.

If he wins even a tenth of what pique has then he has had a good career.

See what football has become.. Once you got Ronaldinho for 30M, now you can't even get a talented teen for 30M..
 

Martindn

New member
See what football has become.. Once you got Ronaldinho for 30M, now you can't even get a talented teen for 30M..

TV income over the past 20 years has increased like 2500%, the world record fee for Pogba is a 600% increase over that same period. It is only going to get worse unfortunately.
 

Zincubus

Banned
So a defender will be better when he doesn't have to............defend?

Most of his blunders were not when he was under pressure actually. He got a loooooooong way to go before even getting compared to Rio Ferdinand. Let alone surpass him. Pique's in another dimension too compared to Stones.

I know it's just your opinion. But no way in hell will that happen.


Same age Rio won englands player of the world cup in 02 and led leeds to a champions league semi-final along side fucking lucas radebe.

Meanwhile Stones can't get ahead of bloody Chris Smalling and Gary Cahill and is too busy falling over every 5 mins in the league.

If he wins even a tenth of what pique has then he has had a good career.

I've kept all these lumped together ....to be quoted later on this season :)


Stones has played two games for City and is already looking something like his old confident self .

He's never gonna be a lion-hearted stopper like Puyol BUT he could easily develop into one of THE best ball playing , technical CBs ... There's even talk about Pep converting him into a sweeper eventually ...or playing the Busq role albeit slightly deeper .
 

Trickykid

Active member
I've kept all these lumped together ....to be quoted later on this season :)


Stones has played two games for City and is already looking something like his old confident self .

He's never gonna be a lion-hearted stopper like Puyol BUT he could easily develop into one of THE best ball playing , technical CBs ... There's even talk about Pep converting him into a sweeper eventually ...or playing the Busq role albeit slightly deeper .

Yeah, quote-digging is fun.

Man City bought Mangala for just £32 million !!!

Quite the deal that, eh?
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top