Kylian Mbappé

raki

New member
I've seen plenty of fans who think Dembele will be better. More think Mbappe is better, give you that, but Barca paid about 160m. on Dembele with addons included, and PSG will pay 180m. for Mbappe.

So, they're both rated ultra high, with not that much between them. Dembele plays for the much bigger club, in the much better league. He has all the tools to become better than Mbappe. Talent wise, they're in the same ball-park as well.

I disagree. Mbappe is a generation player. A phenom.He is on another level.
 

jamrock

Senior Member
Jesus as been kinda meh for a minute now to be honest and he seems more of a great striking talent, that a beast but he as pep so anything is possible.

Sane isn't in the same bracket as mbappe never will be

Dembele is the shit I want to see him put on some muscle & finish better over the years and he will be close to mbappe.

But mbappe man, he is a beast he as the body already, pace he as almost everything expect the eye for a pass which he will never have in a certain way, but if there is a next Messi he will be it.

Unless some other player comes from out of nowhere.

That being said no way will he spend all his career in psg, he doesn't seem to have a Messi or totti mentality.
 

Jair Ventura

New member
Which would be relevant if the reasons were the same which they are not.

Lame stuff.

EPl has plenty great players dont worry about them.

I'm not aware of all the reasons behind Mbappe's decision to remain in France, nor Countinho's decision to force his way to La Liga. I only think it's interesting how adamant you are about good players not wanting to play in Ligue 1 given the EPL's struggles to hold onto the best players of its competition. Countinho gone in the winter, and possibly Hazard in the summer with rumors of departures for Kane, Aguero and de Gea as well.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
I'm not aware of all the reasons behind Mbappe's decision to remain in France, nor Countinho's decision to force his way to La Liga. I only think it's interesting how adamant you are about good players not wanting to play in Ligue 1 given the EPL's struggles to hold onto the best players of its competition. Countinho gone in the winter, and possibly Hazard in the summer with rumors of departures for Kane, Aguero and de Gea as well.

Dont blame any of them for wanting a move to the two biggest clubs in the world but it has no relevance to my opinion that Mbappe will want to test himself week in week out at a top league.

EPL has far more top players across a range of teams than any league in the world dont you worry about them.
 

Jair Ventura

New member
Jesus as been kinda meh for a minute now to be honest and he seems more of a great striking talent, that a beast but he as pep so anything is possible.

Sane isn't in the same bracket as mbappe never will be

Dembele is the shit I want to see him put on some muscle & finish better over the years and he will be close to mbappe.

But mbappe man, he is a beast he as the body already, pace he as almost everything expect the eye for a pass which he will never have in a certain way, but if there is a next Messi he will be it.

Unless some other player comes from out of nowhere.

That being said no way will he spend all his career in psg, he doesn't seem to have a Messi or totti mentality.

You underrate Mbappe's passing. He has 11 assist in 19 matches with PSG, and had 17 in the whole of 2017.
 

Jair Ventura

New member
Dont blame any of them for wanting a move to the two biggest clubs in the world but it has no relevance to my opinion that Mbappe will want to test himself week in week out at a top league.

EPL has far more top players across a range of teams than any league in the world dont you worry about them.


The part you're missing is that Mbappe also had a chance to move to Spain and one of the biggest clubs in the world but turned them down. That's why I mentioned it.
 

jamrock

Senior Member
You underrate Mbappe's passing. He has 11 assist in 19 matches with PSG, and had 17 in the whole of 2017.

Yea his passing is good, no doubt but I'm talking about vision the ability to see and pick out that perfect pass at the right time.

Henry could pass ronaldinho had vision if he get me

The boy is a beast though, no young player in Europe as ba chance of being better than him, he as everything a modern day European football needs.

If someone comes close it will be someone out of south America a short stocky player with a low center of gravity & south American flair.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
The part you're missing is that Mbappe also had a chance to move to Spain and one of the biggest clubs in the world but turned them down. That's why I mentioned it.

Which I have mentioned and said I think he has made a decent move to stay in France for now.

Have also argued that Neymars move can be good for him as well.

Your narrative that my stance is no top player wants to be in France is wrong but cant see any top top player wanting to spend a long time there as testing themselves in better league with more exposure has to be appealing.
 

Jair Ventura

New member
Yea his passing is good, no doubt but I'm talking about vision the ability to see and pick out that perfect pass at the right time.

Henry could pass ronaldinho had vision if he get me

The boy is a beast though, no young player in Europe as ba chance of being better than him, he as everything a modern day European football needs.

If someone comes close it will be someone out of south America a short stocky player with a low center of gravity & south American flair.

Agreed, though some of his passes are special:



 

raki

New member
He really is one of a kind. Some say he rejected Madrid because of uncertainty in playing time. In barça he would be the Neymar replacement. It kills me if barça do no tried to sign him before Dembelé.
 

Wallace

New member
He really is one of a kind. Some say he rejected Madrid because of uncertainty in playing time. In barça he would be the Neymar replacement. It kills me if barça do no tried to sign him before Dembelé.

There is also the fact that he plays alongside Neymar, his great idol, as CR7. Not to mention that he was supporter of PSG when small and his father wanted very much to see him in paris.

I think when he finishes his contract, he will go to Real Madrid.
 

Zincubus

Banned
There is also the fact that he plays alongside Neymar, his great idol, as CR7. Not to mention that he was supporter of PSG when small and his father wanted very much to see him in paris.

I think when he finishes his contract, he will go to Real Madrid.

We should go all out to get MBappe !!

Offer Suarez and any money it takes to get his lad here .

We could THEN rule for the next seven years with this squad
 

Lutece FC

New member
Offer Suarez and any money it takes to get his lad here .
51b764e6e4b0de6db97b584d.gif
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top