On individual basis the singings are good and make sense, including the sales. The problem is that the club does not have good relationship with the players or managers. The cultural policy, the chain of command, the entire "HR", the authority distribution, the management of resources, its all broken, except the finances. When you combine the departure of Xabi Alonso and Di Maria, the outcome is poor. On individual basis, we got a great sum for Xabi and Di Maria, their combined departure is poor. We also loaned out Casemiro so we were really left without depth at all. This killed us. On an individual base, Casemiro benefited a lot, so we get back a better player. On the whole? The midfield was destroyed, the one that played in the previous CL campaign that won us the title. We depended on two new comers, Toni and James, then Modric got injured, with no depth. So...good transfers, bad policy.
Ozil's departure makes sense as a sale out of context, but combine it with Bale and his fee, did it make sense in retrospect? No. There is solid ground to argue that Bale is not an upgrade at all. Ozil's problem is that he was mentally fragile compared to Di Maria (and Isco?) who wanted to fight for a position.
I have no problem with the James transfer, I love him. He is no Di Maria though (has its pros and cons). There really was no purpose in selling Morata when we have no depth and Jese just came back from a terrible injury. We ended up with Benzema unchallenged, and sometimes, lacking that bite.
Sometimes i wonder if staying too long in Canada has dropped the blood supply to your brains buddy... it's getting scary with your latest posts
Selling Xabi at that age for that amount .. making hell lot of money from Ozil , Higuain , Di Maria ...
Xabi was old and getting clumsy * you can see what it matters the most for Bayern last season * .. he can dominate the small games but big games need younger legs... i will not forget he could have costed us the final with his dumbest yellow card in the semi-final second leg when the result was way beyond any team reach... we had to play Khedira... i say no more
Di Maria one of the bright stars of La Decima season but as far as it pains me it looks like we were right to sell moreover when you say poor you easily disregard how we smoked every tom , dick & harry for half a season including an emphatic & convincing win over the treble winners Barcelona.. we were way ahead in the driver seat until fatigue struck in & that's basically Carlo problem.. for so many games the results were fine he could have rested both Kroos & Modric... last year was not about missing Di Maria hell we played even better with James but it was a poor management by Carlo and probably nothing triggered his departure except looking back at how the team fell flat in 2-3 month of the second half of the season..
As for Ozil are you kidding me ? fragile ? Ozil 5 AM nightlife & poor fitness (remember he never played well over 60 minutes in any game )was reported extensively in the Spanish press... i remember Cule's here were laughing when we sent him packing eventually whoever replaced him was influential in both trophies won when he left including the much coveted la decima.. and Isco provided much more consistency ..
As for Bale replacing Ozil.. as i said it seems there is lack of blood flow to the brains my friend due to Canada weather...
Mourinho = 4-2-3-1 = Ozil is the AM
Carlo = 4-3-3 = No AM in the first season = Bale-Ronaldo-Benzema front 3 , Xabi-Modric-Di Maria midfield...
So Bale was not an upgrade to Ozil.. he is BETTER THAN OZIL in Carlo 4-3-3 formation & Ozil would have struggled both with fitness and as RW
as for the front part
Real Madrid is by far the best run club in the world..
I wonder if you know how close is the relation between Perez & Ronaldo /Benzema? or how Jose angel Sanchez (the Bad cop to Perez good cop ) and Mourinho who still rave about his relation with both ?
Under Perez he gets the Galactico's the manager gets the rest ... advisers such as Zidane played a huge role in getting Varane and elevating Benzema to another level
The club loan a young gun for a year and see if he is worth it is pretty successful on all fronts ..either he makes it & return ala De La Red , Carvajal , Casemiro or prove he is not on the same level (or not needed at the time) and the club makes big money out of him ala Soldado, Negredo etc
compare that to all the failed attempts to copy us from big guns... take Barca from Gabi to Bojan all the way to Denis Suarez & Def. etc or United's Wilfried Zaha or Macheda etc
The buyback clause is now standard for big teams ..
you can say we don't meet the required sport success but management wise..99.9% of other clubs would love to be run as successful as we are ... if Barcelona didn't have their best generation in history Real would probably have won 2-3 more Champions league and 5-6 liga's but it's their time the fact that we did manage leagues under the nose of Messi-Xavi-Ronaldinho and co and even got our Champions league says it all... it is the Barcelona era in the past decade and we do have to acknowledge that as well as acknowledging Messi will probably go down in history as the best ever ... it's an unusual circumstances but happens every once in a blue moon like our Di Stefano team , Cruyff Ajax team , the Caesar Bayern Munich team , The Dutch trio Milan team.. it just happens that's why such teams are memorable
As for Kovacic, the more I think about it, the more I love this signing. I complained before on how we have not many dribblers on the team, but we got one, and important one. Kroos for all his heroecs last season, I don't care for him as much, as he can only dribbled into space, or for the protection of the ball. We have Marcelo and Isco (ran with the ball more than Messi, more than anyone else from La Liga), the rest including James are not that great dribbling at great lengths. Carvajal is also good to be fair. Kovacic averaged more passes per game than our players in midfield.
I am not sure if his best position is to play the Modric role or not, I have my doubts, but he has the tools and skills, lets see.
Man it's not about dribblers.. it's about moving with the ball the way Modric do.. a box to box who can hold the ball well and gain space
James is a great dribbler but different set of skills.. he is more latin .. Kova especially his roulette dribbles remind me more of Zidane because he keeps the ball within his legs away from defenders reach.. anyhow he is an exciting talent & we'll wait to see how he develops