Nelson Semedo

Alik

Moderator
Good performance? He's rubbish. The team cannot build an attack when he starts, he either always turns around and passes backwards or he gets to the final third and shits himself.

A new right back is an absolute must in the summer. Sameido is backup at the very best.

I don't think he had a good performance either or that he is starter quality, but he was much better than Roberto.
 

Cool

Senior Member
I feel bad for him, whatever he can do and offer to the team the response he gets from Valvarde is warming the bench.

Today, he helped us get the penatly and despite being shaky in the first 10 minutes he recollected himself.
 

eaman

Active member
I feel bad for him, whatever he can do and offer to the team the response he gets from Valvarde is warming the bench.

Today, he helped us get the penatly and despite being shaky in the first 10 minutes he recollected himself.

I agree he did some nice things and won the penalty but there was a few miscontrols under no pressure that doesn't help
 

PhilS

Active member
Still does not play like a Barca player. You must be able to hold your own in the passing game to deserve to start for this team, I'm just not seeing the vision or the skills from either Semedo or Vidal. Semedo fits less well than Vidal, though his make-up speed on defense is quite helpful. Could continue as a rotation option, but he is just not showing Barca starter quality.
 

xXKonan

Senior Member
Still does not play like a Barca player. You must be able to hold your own in the passing game to deserve to start for this team, I'm just not seeing the vision or the skills from either Semedo or Vidal. Semedo fits less well than Vidal, though his make-up speed on defense is quite helpful. Could continue as a rotation option, but he is just not showing Barca starter quality.
He may not be like a Barca Player but he's still far away our Best Right Back.

Roberto may be better in possession but what use is that when the guy gets torn to shreds on a consistent basis?
 

Givenchy

Senior Member
he has everything in him to make a top RB, he just needs to start. whether its Malcom or Dembele ahead of him he plays great
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top