Messigician
Senior Member
Yeah of course. We have Adam Curry working on the transfer as we speak
Neymar Jr.
- Thread starter El Flaco
- Start date
- Status
Yeah of course. We have Adam Curry working on the transfer as we speak
I'd rather he worked on a Vindaloo.
MTL_Barca
Well-known member
serghei
Senior Member
Yep. Always good when superstars regret leaving Barcelona for PSG. Neymar is a cautionary tale about what happens when you leave the center stage of football to follow the qatari money.
He traded El Clasico for PSG - Lille
.
Leo_Messi
New member
I think that the explanation is rather simple. Leonardo took over and wants to create a genuine team rather than a collection of a few individual stars with egos the size of Siberia. Neymar never really having settled in Paris, Ligue 1 being Ligue 1 and the Qatari ambitions of becoming the dominant club in Europe having turned into a massive fiasco so far. That and Neymar knowing that Mbappé is not going to stay long-term nor himself. Money (insane paychecks) can only do so much. PSG will remain PSG.
If you recall I discussed Mbappé in detail months ago where many users where proclaiming him to be the reincarnation of a prime Messi, Maradona, Ronaldo and Pelé put together. I still don't think that he will ever become better than a prime Henry.
Neymar is the superior talent and player but he is damaged goods and his purchase opens up a giant pandora box. Not worth the hassle. So if I could pick I would take the inferior but almost 7 years younger Mbappé if I insisted on buying a PSG player.
Anyway I think it is a question of time until a better talent than Mbappé emerges and when that happens the club should be ready to pounce. Hopefully with a new board from 2021 onwards.
Adam Curry?
André Cury you mean.
Never_Forget40
Banned
Yes! Mbappe is such an overrated player. He misses so many chances 1 vs 1 chances against the goalkeeper, cant play magical passes, can only dribble because of his speed like prime CR7. He will never reach the GOAT level, even CR7 will be miles better than him.
serghei
Senior Member
Prime CR7 was on a different level to Mbappe. Mbappe is lucky if he reaches half the level of Messi/Cristiano Ronaldo.
xXKonan
Senior Member
Funny thing is PSG's issues with Squad depth, especially in the Midfield is tied to both signing Mbappe and Neymar.
It was a brilliant idea to spend a total of 400+Million on two forwards, but have little money to actually reinforce the Midfield and build an actual good enough team overall especially a team that has had FFP issues for years now.
The irony of it is, Neymar wants to GTFO and Mbappe doesn't seem he wants to stick around for very long regardless if Ney leaves or not.
It was a brilliant idea to spend a total of 400+Million on two forwards, but have little money to actually reinforce the Midfield and build an actual good enough team overall especially a team that has had FFP issues for years now.
The irony of it is, Neymar wants to GTFO and Mbappe doesn't seem he wants to stick around for very long regardless if Ney leaves or not.
Never_Forget40
Banned
Yeah Messi and Ronaldo destroyed the best teams at the world while Mbappe is 'destroying' Bordeaux, Caen, Montepellier
Leo_Messi
New member
A 34 year old Ronaldo is better and more clutch right now IMO. I would rather have CR7 in a CL final than the current version of Mbappé. Call me delusional if you want to. Let alone in CR7's prime.
Mbappé would be lucky to reach the prime of Henry and stay on that level throughout his prime. When people on this forum where comparing him with Ronaldo (El Fenómeno), I could hardly believe the ignorance, delusion or low level of trolling.
Anyway I would still take Mbappé over Neymar. Mostly due to age and unfulfilled potential. Mbappé might very likely never be as good as a 100% focused and ready Neymar (very doubtful at least) but nothing points to him becoming the circus clown that Neymar has been for years.
After the triplete season (2014-15) when a 22-23 year old Neymar was causing havoc against all the top clubs that we faced in the CL, I had big hopes of him eventually becoming a worthy successor of Messi but he pissed that opportunity away due to not taking football seriously, due to his chaotic private life, toxic entourage and becoming content with what he had already achieved.
I don't see that hunger or winner mentality in him despite the abundance of talent unlike in say Mbappé. A shame really.
If he returns this summer, which I would not rule out at all, I hope that he will take this last opportunity and become the best player in the world and take the mantle from a 33 year old Messi. Even if his reign would only be short-lived (2-3 years). If (a big if) he gets his life in order and goes all-in with a vengeance to prove every doubter wrong and repay his moronic and unforgivable stunt back in 2017, he will earn my highest respect and that of the football world. It is all in his hands should he arrive. I don't think that it will happen but I cannot rule it out either. The talent is clearly there. Always was.
Last edited:
- Status
Home of Barca Fans
