He didn't have a good game but no one did play well. Verratti had some highlights that game. Other than that, very dreadful game. Neymar had some poor touch but was also the only offensive player trying. Remember Tuchel gameplan is pass the ball to Neymar. However, with no Mbapp? to play with, no width (Bakker is probably surprised himself he was playing with Bernat not fit and Kurzawa, injured during the game, playing on the right due to the right fullbacks being unfit aswell), an useless Icardi (9 balls), and useless Gueye, there isn't much to do either.
If it was usual Neymar performance, we would be more than happy to ship him to Bar?a for even 100 M.
He won't do much against Atalanta either. We had already very slim chances and our only very very fit player was Mbapp?. Tactically, Mbapp? was the biggest threat for Atalanta because they like to play a very high pressing and you know how dangerous Mbapp? can be if you let him space in behind. The recipe was to get Verratti or Neymar to send him fast test their defence. Now, Mbapp? is either out or not fully fit for the tie. PSG is screwed.