Fati - Vardy - Memphis
Tielmans - Ndidi - Dejong
Alba - Evans - Pique - Perieria
Schmeichel
7-5 for Leicester
(I'm not counting 2021/2022 as I don't have a full season worth of performances, yet. So guys like Memphis are out).
For me it's:
Barnes - Vardy - Messi
Tielemans - De Jong - Ndidi
Alba - Evans - Soyuncu - Pereira
Schmeichel
Soyuncu's debut season was fantastic and far above 2019-2021's Pique, in my honest opinion. I seriously just don't rate Barcelona's defense outside of Alba. Leicester's far more solid defensively on an individual level. Once again based on performances.
I can't place Fati in the lineup as he doesn't even have a season of playtime, and he's been injured. Though I think talent wise he is higher than Barnes. I also think Dembele's "talent" is also higher than Barnes, but Barnes has been the more reliable performer and has had very good end product for the past 2 years.
Same as Vardy. Doesn't have Suarez's talent, but I'd pick his performances over the past 2 years over Suarez's.
Schmeichel over Ter Stegen for obvious reasons.
Like I said, 3 from Barcelona.
It is my firm these guys aren't rated higher because they wear a Leicester shirt. I'm 100% sure once Tielemans and Pereira move to elite teams (which they will), they will be designated as world class players. I rate Tielemans quite highly, one of the best CMs in the league.
This isn't the same as saying Barcelona's team is shit, I think it's still comfortably a regular UCL team. Just that the PL is way more top heavy than any other league right now that even a 5th placed team can match up quite well against the European elite.