Premier League 24/25

Who will win?

  • Total voters
    29
Fati_Future_BallonDor

Fati_Future_BallonDor

Well-known member
Maradona37 said:
We'll see mate. To me their two most technically gifted players are Lisandro and Amad. Though the former is prone to the odd mistake. They need more players like that and less like McTominay, Wank Bissaka, Casemiro, Lindelof, Maguire, Onana etc.

I think they'll struggle again but we will see.
Click to expand...

Yep ive always say Manu have too many trash players, Casemiro or McT arent too bad to start but they dont have many other options, think they will still achieve third place 💯
 
Fati_Future_BallonDor

Fati_Future_BallonDor

Well-known member
soul24rage said:
------------------Zirkzee
Rashford--------Fernandes--------Garnacho
-------------Mainoo----Collyer
Shaw-------Lisandro----Yoro-------Dalot
-------------------Onana

Solid XI
Click to expand...

Amrabat? :pique:

Edit: Amrabat isnt at Manu anymore?😳

But sancho is still there, put Rashy as striker and sancho lw
 
Maradona37

Maradona37

Well-known member
I normally agree with you on football soul24rage, but I don't rate the majority of those players in the slightest.

And even if they are good, they never seem to play cohesive football anyway. They're just a collection of players thrown together and nobody has been able to coach them, including Ten Hag.

I acknowledge though that I hate the club so I am negatively biased against them.
 
soul24rage

soul24rage

Senior Member
Maradona37 said:
I normally agree with you on football soul24rage, but I don't rate the majority of those players in the slightest.

And even if they are good, they never seem to play cohesive football anyway. They're just a collection of players thrown together and nobody has been able to coach them, including Ten Hag.

I acknowledge though that I hate the club so I am negatively biased against them.
Click to expand...
I guess it depends on what we are rating them as. With this starting XI, I rate them as a 4th/5th placed team. They are no where near enough for 1st or 2nd imo and their squad depth is bad for a top 4 side.

I would also preferably get an actual CM (like an Equi Fernandez) instead of Fernandes who can help dominate the midfield and I still don't rate Onana as a GK (reminds me of MATS).

Some transfer rumours are weird like Ugarte and De Ligt, but the way Ineos is acting seem a bit promising.
 
Maradona37

Maradona37

Well-known member
soul24rage said:
I guess it depends on what we are rating them as. With this starting XI, I rate them as a 4th/5th placed team. They are no where near enough for 1st or 2nd imo and their squad depth is bad for a top 4 side.

I would also preferably get an actual CM (like an Equi Fernandez) instead of Fernandes who can help dominate the midfield and I still don't rate Onana as a GK (reminds me of MATS).

Some transfer rumours are weird like Ugarte and De Ligt, but the way Ineos is acting seem a bit promising.
Click to expand...
I'd likely play Amad on the right over Garnacho, I think he's better technically, though Garnacho is younger and has more credit in the bank.

However, yeah I would go along with most of that. Fernandes creates chances but he hampers the way they play because he isn't able to control games and tries the hero ball every time, often resulting in them conceding possession. Risk-taking is good, but he doesn't strike the right balance in my opinion and goes too far with risks. He's a creative player but not calm and composed enough and poor in tight spaces.

I don't rate Onana either, poor saving technique and an accident waiting to happen. His short kicking is good but his long kicking is mediocre.

Ugarte looks a destroyer type, which isn't what they need for me. They need a DM or CM who can get his foot on the ball and set the tempo, receive the ball from the centre-backs and get them playing. From what I have watched that's not Ugarte.

As for De Ligt, he's someone I have always found was better when younger and had hype - his career has stalled and I suppose they'll be hoping to reverse his regression if they get him. It does seem weird though that they keep targeting Ten Hag's old players - Mazraoui too this summer.

But we'll see. I think the competition is quite good in that league, so I am not really convinced they even have a top 5 team based on that lineup. But even if they do, the far bigger point is they need to get the chemistry right and get them playing structured football. It might look a good team to some on paper but Man United's problem has been getting their team to gel on grass. They lack depth too and it's a squad game now.

Good discussion though. It's interesting to think about who will do well next season.
 
soul24rage

soul24rage

Senior Member
Maradona37 said:
I'd likely play Amad on the right over Garnacho, I think he's better technically, though Garnacho is younger and has more credit in the bank.

However, yeah I would go along with most of that. Fernandes creates chances but he hampers the way they play because he isn't able to control games and tries the hero ball every time, often resulting in them conceding possession. Risk-taking is good, but he doesn't strike the right balance in my opinion and goes too far with risks. He's a creative player but not calm and composed enough and poor in tight spaces.

I don't rate Onana either, poor saving technique and an accident waiting to happen. His short kicking is good but his long kicking is mediocre.

Ugarte looks a destroyer type, which isn't what they need for me. They need a DM or CM who can get his foot on the ball and set the tempo, receive the ball from the centre-backs and get them playing. From what I have watched that's not Ugarte.

As for De Ligt, he's someone I have always found was better when younger and had hype - his career has stalled and I suppose they'll be hoping to reverse his regression if they get him. It does seem weird though that they keep targeting Ten Hag's old players - Mazraoui too this summer.

But we'll see. I think the competition is quite good in that league, so I am not really convinced they even have a top 5 team based on that lineup. But even if they do, the far bigger point is they need to get the chemistry right and get them playing structured football. It might look a good team to some on paper but Man United's problem has been getting their team to gel on grass. They lack depth too and it's a squad game now.

Good discussion though. It's interesting to think about who will do well next season.
Click to expand...
I'd rather have Garnacho on the LW and Amad on the RW as I rate Amad. But seems like Rashford is undroppable for ETH imo.

The team has a lot of clean up to do.
 
Maradona37

Maradona37

Well-known member
soul24rage said:
I'd rather have Garnacho on the LW and Amad on the RW as I rate Amad. But seems like Rashford is undroppable for ETH imo.

The team has a lot of clean up to do.
Click to expand...
Yeah I was gonna say that, I would have Garnacho on the left over Rashy. Some United fans think Garnacho is better on the right, but I think that's a temporary thing as he is tempted to always come inside and shoot on the left. As he gets more mature and smarter he should become better on the left.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Home of Barca Fans

Top