I get what you're saying but:
Barca DNA scored eight goals yesterday. High pressing, Gegenpressing, Ultra-high defense line, moving the ball fast, compactness, consistent overloading, excellent synergies - and also athleticism.
When was athleticism a part of Barca's DNA?
Our only atheticism during Cruijff and Pep was some stamina, pressing and pace in some players.
We historically almost never relied on:
Attacking crosses
Headers
Height
Defensive height
Fighting spirit
Bayern and Germans usually always have a mix of:
Physique
Technique
Mental strength
Never give up spirit
Leaders
A fighting spirit
We usually have:
Very high technique
Ultra expensive 2-3 magicians like Rivaldo, Ronaldinho, Messi, Neymar
We historically never had allround teams with:
Height
Muscles
Huge aerial strength
Insane stamina
Filled with leaders
Combative spirit
I am not sure how anyone can seriously compare German football and ideas with our classical light and funny Barca DNA.
Barca DNA had some pace and pressing.
But physique, height, aerial strength and mental/combative skills were never our strengths.
Our strengths are possession and an insane individual power by Ballon d or magicians like Stoichkov, Ronnie or Messi.
For me, in roots, Barca DNA and our possession football built around short, soft midfielders is and will not be compatible with Europen football and winning titles in the future.
Btw, playing with Raki-Vidal is not the answer either.
But the future of winning football is closer to Zidane's RM, Klopp's Liverpool, Bayern, Germany from 2014.
A mix of technique, physique, killer finishing, mental strength, more directness.
And lol: being able to score from possession, counters and crosses.
Rm, Bayern, Germans.
They can all score from possession, counters and from crosses/headers.
Barca: during Cruijff and Pep we had possession and counters.
We never relied on headers and crosses.
So, we had 2 weapons and others have 3 weapons.
Today we lost even pace and counters, so we have only one scoring weapon: shortpasses/possession.
We can add Dembele and more pace, but again we will have only two weapons at max (possession and counters).
So, to beat teams with 3 weapons, we need to be better than them at possession and counters.
And we were able to do that ONLY with prime Messi-Xavi.
Barca DNA is imo flawed because we rely on only two weapons.
We hate height, crosses, headers.
On top of that, add our obssession with a lack of pace, stamina and muscles paired with our culture of being overly nice (choirboys).
I have literally watched a movie about La Masia where coaches explain how they teach kids core values from the age 6: to be nice, humble and not to fight.
I mean, those are nice traits to be a good friend and to help to your ageing grandmother.
But being overly nice and humble is not compatible with top level sport/competition/war in 2020.
So, yes, I blame Barca DNA:
1. We hate height, crosses and headers since always
2. We raise our kids to be too nice persons and to never fight.
And then 20 years later in CL quarters and semis, you get a bunch of Iniestas, Busis (and probably Puigs in the future) who get both physically and mentally bullied by Germans and Englishmen, who are not "as nice and polite".
Those core Barca DNA flaws can win ONLY on rare occassions when we have prime Messi and a team which is 200% better than anyone on a technical level.
When the quality is 50:50, we stand almost no chance.
I mean, there is a reason why Barca gets bullied on every away KO match since Cruijff (who had 16-17% of away KO matches wins, and Pep who had 20% of wins).
Why?
= kids who are raised to be overly nice and humble and not to fight with anyone
= a lack of physical skills for hostile away stadiums where home teams run at 120% (paired with 80 000 home fans, mental bullying and pressure on our players)
Can you imagine Germans getting bullied by anyone with 7:0 or 8:0?
Can you imagine our short, light, choirboys getting bullied since always by the same type of teams?
Lol, I can.
It started with Cruijff in 1994, 4:0 for Milan.
A classical Barca.
Beaten on a physical level.
And beaten on a mental strength level.