Should I stay or should I go?

[Hellsangel]

Simple: divide the entire squad in three groups: "100% should stay", "100% should go" and "still in doubt". This according to what you think is best, not what will happen.

100% SHOULD STAY
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
22. Dani Alves
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto

DOUBTFUL
2. Montoya
7. Pedro
14. Mascherano
25. Oier
21. Adriano

 

[Gaudi]

100% SHOULD STAY
3. Piqué
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba
14. Mascherano
21. Adriano
2. Montoya

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
22. Dani Alves
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca

DOUBTFUL
7. Pedro
9. Alexis
4. Fàbregas
24. Sergi Roberto
25. Oier

 

[Flavia]

100% SHOULD STAY
2. Montoya
3. Piqué
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
10. Messi
11. Neymar
14. Mascherano
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba
22. Alves

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto
25. Oier

DOUBTFUL
4. Cesc
7. Pedro
9. Alexis
21. Adriano

 

[Egert]

100% SHOULD STAY
2.Montoya
3.Pique
4.Cesc
6.Xavi
7.Pedro
8.Iniesta
10.Messi
11.Neymar
14.Masche
15.Bartra
16.Bossquets
18.Jordi Alba
21.Adriano
24.Sergi Roberto

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1.Valdes
5.Puyol
12.Dos Santos
13.Pinto
17.Song
19.Afellay
20.Tello
22.Alves
23.Cuenca
25.Oier

DOUBTFUL
9.Alexis

 

[hardyboy]

100% SHOULD STAY
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba
2. Montoya
7. Pedro
14. Mascherano

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
22. Dani Alves
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca

DOUBTFUL
9.Alexis
25. Oier
21. Adriano
24. Sergi Roberto

 

[KingMessi]

I feel like we should divide the 100% Should Leave into two sections: one for 100% Should be Sold and one for 100% Should be Loaned.

100% Should Stay
2. Montoya
3. Pique
4. Fabregas
6. Xavi
7. Pedro
8. Iniesta
10. Messi
11. Neymar
14. Mascherano
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba
21. Adriano

100% Should be Loaned
24. Roberto
20. Tello (if we can't get decent money for him)
Denis Suarez

100% Should be Sold
1. Valdes (he can stay if Monaco doesn't honor his precontract)
5. Puyol
12. JDS
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello (if we can get decent money for him, with OPTIONAL buyback)
22. Alves
23. Cuenca (with OPTIONAL buyback)
25. Oier
Bojan

Doubtful
9. Sanchez

 

[macleod]

We are fans and we have opinion,but the situation is other.Logics for me players who leave will be:Valdes,Pinto,maybe Oier;Puyol;Song;Alexis,Cuenca,Afellay,Tello and maybe on loan Dos Santos.

 

[Deco 20]

Getting rid of too many players could destabilize the team.

100% SHOULD STAY
2. Montoya
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba
21. Adriano

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto

DOUBTFUL
7. Pedro
13. Pinto
14. Mascherano
17. Song
22. Dani Alves
25. Oier

 

[DonAK]

The worst part is if we sell way too many players and replace them with bums.

 

[serghei]

Getting rid of too many players could destabilize the team.

100% SHOULD STAY
2. Montoya
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba
21. Adriano

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto

DOUBTFUL
7. Pedro
13. Pinto
14. Mascherano
17. Song
22. Dani Alves
25. Oier

+1. Alves and Pedro on 100% should stay. Everything else is spot on for my liking.

The worst part is if we sell way too many players and replace them with bums.

That's actually very possible. Making changes does not guarantee evolution. Only the right changes can do that. And the right changes are thought out by the right people. And it seems we have the wrong people.

 

[voodoomaster]

Can someone explain why Masch should leave? He is a very good player - can handle cb, rb, dm very well. He still has some years left on top level. And every fucking time he goes out on the field he gives 110 percent - can you say that of many of our players? Monsterano MUST stay.

 

[Cutty]

100% SHOULD STAY

• Andrés Iniesta
• Cesc Fàbregas
• Gerard Deulofeu
• Gerard Piqué
• Jordi Alba
• Lionel Messi
• Marc Bartra
• Martín Montoya
• Neymar Júnior
• Rafa Alcântara
• Sergi Roberto
• Sergio Busquets
• Xavi Hernández

100% SHOULD LEAVE

• Adriano Correia
• Alex Song
• Bojan Krkić
• Carles Puyol
• Cristian Tello
• Dani Alves
• Ibrahim Afellay
• Isaac Cuenca
• Javier Mascherano
• Jonathan dos Santos
• José Manuel Pinto
• Keirrison Carneiro
• Oier Olazábal
• Víctor Valdés

DOUBTFUL

• Alexis Sánchez
• Pedro Rodríguez Ledesma

 

[Alarcón]

100% SHOULD STAY
2. Montoya
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
7. Pedro
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdés
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
14. Mascherano
19. Afellay
20. Tello
22. Alves
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto (loan)
25. Oier

DOUBTFUL

6. Xavi (if he doesn't accept the bench)
17. Song (only if we get a good replacement)
21. Adriano (I could live with him but there are countless better left backs)

 

[darthvader7888]

Should stay:
3. Piqué
6. Xavi
8. Iniesta
10. Messi
11. Neymar
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba

Should leave:
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto

Doubtful:
2. Montoya
4. Fàbregas
7. Pedro
9. Alexis
14. Mascherano
25. Oier
21. Adriano
22. Dani Alves

 

[Alik]

100% SHOULD STAY
3. Piqué
4. Fàbregas
6. Xavi
7. Pedro
8. Iniesta
9. Alexis
10. Messi
11. Neymar
14. Mascherano
15. Bartra
16. Busquets
18. Alba

100% SHOULD LEAVE
1. Valdes
5. Puyol
12. Dos Santos
13. Pinto
17. Song
19. Afellay
20. Tello
23. Cuenca
24. Sergi Roberto
25. Oier

DOUBTFUL
22. Dani Alves
2. Montoya
21. Adriano