Which "number 8" is better? Kaka or Iniesta

[Valon]

and that's when you really should be worried about yourself

 

[Snyde]

I'd say this about the Messi/Iniesta argument: (The only thing worth talking about in this thread )

They are both tremendously fantastic and at a very close level. Iniesta is obviously more like by others than Messi because of the type of person he is and that (perhaps subconsciously) makes them biased. Messi has much, much more end product while Iniesta does the work without grabbing the spotlight. (much like Xavi) In their dribbling styles Iniesta's intelligence shines more than his natural talent while it is opposite for Messi but both of them have both these things in great quantities.

Zanela's own sig. speaks alot about players like Xavi, Iniesta. IMO there is not too much difference between the two and I find that saying one is better than the other is useless. (while saying one is much better than the other is bullshit)
And personally, I wouldn't take either of them over the other, I'd just thank god and count myself lucky that Barca have both.

 

[antonnn]

I'd say this about the Messi/Iniesta argument: (The only thing worth talking about in this thread )

They are both tremendously fantastic and at a very close level. Iniesta is obviously more like by others than Messi because of the type of person he is and that (perhaps subconsciously) makes them biased. Messi has much, much more end product while Iniesta does the work without grabbing the spotlight. (much like Xavi) In their dribbling styles Iniesta's intelligence shines more than his natural talent while it is opposite for Messi but both of them have both these things in great quantities.

Exactly(other than the bit about being bias ). Iniesta is probably AM version of Makelele, though he gets more spotlight than Makelele did!

 

[Snyde]

As of now he does but before?

 

[antonnn]

Yeah before he didn't, most people only took real notice of him this season. I've thought he was very good for years now, but this season was really his breakout season, awesome player.

 

[sammy]

I always admire him, we are blessed not paying 65 mil euro to get him

 

[AnfieldEd]

IMO Iniesta is the best player in the world.

For me it is that simple at this moment in time I think he is. I don't know why Zanela has this attitude problem regards this issue. We all know Messi is world class and is a legend in the making. But others like myself see Iniesta as a better all round player.

 

[maz]

I dont think zenela has an attitude problem. She is just arguing her case. Im enjoying reading the debate between her and anton.

Although as i said a few months back, iniesta = zidane, messi = maradona.

 

[sammy]

And platini said what zidane could do with a ball, maradona could done the same thing but with an orange fruit.

 

[zanela]

IMO Iniesta is the best player in the world.

For me it is that simple at this moment in time I think he is. I don't know why Zanela has this attitude problem regards this issue. We all know Messi is world class and is a legend in the making. But others like myself see Iniesta as a better all round player.

Let me remind u tht this is a forum, a place where ppl 've diff opinions, a place to debate. I disagree abt Iniesta to be the best in the world and have stated my reasons for it unlike u who has to resort to other member's posts to backup ur opinion...

If u think its an attitude prob thn every member on this forum has it...

I dont think zenela has an attitude problem. She is just arguing her case. Im enjoying reading the debate between her and anton.

Although as i said a few months back, iniesta = zidane, messi = maradona.

Thnks Maz. Ur not only the smartest but also the nicest on here

 

[Labinn]

Iniesta

.

 

[MinaFCB]

Kaka is nice and so...but ppl Iniesta is a living legend!Impossible to compare!

 

[VivaBarca]

I voted Iniesta... second best player in the world.

Exactly, same as me.

 

[BarcaCelt]

Not biased in the sligt, but Iniesta by a clear mile. Kaka gives the ball away too much I've noticed, despite his wonderful talents he has more flaws than Iniesta. I love the way Iniesta tries to play, protecting the ball, precise passing and intelligent through balls, its wonderful to watch.

 

[FCB_Titi_LB]

Not biased in the sligt, but Iniesta by a clear mile. Kaka gives the ball away too much I've noticed, despite his wonderful talents he has more flaws than Iniesta. I love the way Iniesta tries to play, protecting the ball, precise passing and intelligent through balls, its wonderful to watch.

+1

but really not comparable players...Kaka rushes