ccesc
New member
Lahm? ok- yes he might be better. But I think Piszczek is better at crossing and he is faster. Hard to say for me.
Neuer? No way. There are even better GK in Bundesliga.
World XI
- Thread starter VivaBarca
- Start date
Lahm? ok- yes he might be better. But I think Piszczek is better at crossing and he is faster. Hard to say for me.
Neuer? No way. There are even better GK in Bundesliga.
mixer
New member
Piszczek better at crossing than Lahm? No way. And I'm saying this as a Pole. He's faster but Lahm isn't slow either.
Which goalkeppers are better than Neuer in your opinion?
ccesc
New member
In germany? Rene Adler. And Weidenfeller got fewer mistakes then Neuer and better reflexes. But Neuer is better as a playing Goalkeeper with his foot.
Btw. last Season Piszczek scored 4 goals + 14 assists (in 53 games). Lahm 0 goals, 20 assists (in 54 games). Piszczek played half a season injured and Bayern was way better in Bundesliga.
2011/2012: Piszczek 4 goals 12 assists in 54 games. Lahm: 1 goal, 5 assists in 58 games
But all in all you are right. Im Dortmund fan and hate Bayern. So I cant be objective. This is football. There are always discussions about teams and players. This is one point why we love the game, right!?
te amo barca
Blaugrana al vent
-------------any German GK------------
----Kompany-----Hummels------Thiago Silva
----------Busquets--------A.Pirlo---------
-----Reus---------Iniesta----------C.Ronaldo
----------Messi--------------Neymar(Falcao, Cavani, Lewandowski)
----Kompany-----Hummels------Thiago Silva
----------Busquets--------A.Pirlo---------
-----Reus---------Iniesta----------C.Ronaldo
----------Messi--------------Neymar(Falcao, Cavani, Lewandowski)
Glad someone else acknowledges how good Di Maria is his work rate and chance creation is top class.
ejuventus
New member
Falcao
Ronaldo --- Iniesta ---- Messi
Vidal --- Schweisteiger
Marcelo -- T. Silva -- Barzagli -- Lahm
Neuer
Ronaldo --- Iniesta ---- Messi
Vidal --- Schweisteiger
Marcelo -- T. Silva -- Barzagli -- Lahm
Neuer
I regret not to put Ribery and Robben neither, but there are too great champions nowadays
I regret also about Xavi, but that formation it takes a strong midfield line, reason for what I didn't put Pirlo either
So, I was thinking about how teams would look like if they were done continent-based. UEFA XI vs CONMEBOL XI for instance...
My SA team would look like..
___________Rafael______________
Cuadrado___T.Silva___Godin___F.Luís
_________Masch__Vidal_________
ADM_________Messi________Neymar
____________Falcao_____________
vs
___________Buffon________________
Lahm____Hummels____Chiellini___Azpi
_____________D.Rossi____________
________Modrić_______Reus_______
Robben_______Lewa______C.Ronaldo
I like to see more line-ups on this theme..
My SA team would look like..
___________Rafael______________
Cuadrado___T.Silva___Godin___F.Luís
_________Masch__Vidal_________
ADM_________Messi________Neymar
____________Falcao_____________
vs
___________Buffon________________
Lahm____Hummels____Chiellini___Azpi
_____________D.Rossi____________
________Modrić_______Reus_______
Robben_______Lewa______C.Ronaldo
I like to see more line-ups on this theme..
footyfan
Calma, calma
I made one 1.5 years ago on this thread:
As of today, I would go with your lineup, with the following changes:
Suarez for Falcao
Schweinsteiger for Reus
Ramos for Chiellini.
Edit: Oh and of course, the very obvious change - Neuer for Buffon.
Last edited:
Ramos, despite his attacking aerial prowess, is too erratic as a pure defender.
Reus is undroppable for the versatility and the goal threat he carries. His presence allows for diff. in-game formations. On that note, when some posters want us to pass up on Reus because we've X,Y,Z on the roster. My reaction =
It was between Falcao and Suarez for me. I went with the more likable option. Now come to think of it, with Cheillini there, Suarez makes more sense.
I don't rate/like Manuela. So you can say some of my selections are biased. But replacing Buffon with Manuela willl also be more fun..
How I think the match 'd unfold..
A high-octane all action packed blockbuster. Both teams coming close to finding the net. But being denied by keeper heroics, both sides. The match tied goal-less enters injury time. Ronaldo wins a fk on the left wing. Cristiano thinks its in Cristiano's range, and tells off the li'l Croat. As the world watches with baited breath, Ronaldo lines-up his shot. The ball flies in (almost), but is headed out by Godin. The ball finds messi, and he's on his magical run. There's no stopping the li'l dictator, until he sights the (un)godly giant frame of Manuela outside the box. The world stands still, Leo takes a pause, and spots the emerging figure of a Tarantula next to him. He squares it to Cuadrado. And its game. set. match to TeamLatino.
Winner be like..
Loser be like..
Manimals unable to contain the euphoria be like ..
My sweetheart be like..
What are you looking at Ppl? Go Home.
Muttu
Member
As for my teams:
EU
-------------------------Neuer------------------------
-Lahm-------Hummels------Mathieu----------Alba-
-------------------Schweinsteiger-------------------
----------------Modrić---------Reus-----------------
-Robben-------------Ibrahimović----------Ronaldo-
vs
SA
-------------------------Navas-------------------------
-Zabaleta--------Silva------Godín--------------Luis-
---------------------Mascherano----------------------
---------------Vidal-----------Di María----------------
-------------------------Messi--------------------------
---------------Suarez--------Neymar-----------------
Last edited:
Home of Barca Fans
