Busquets has never been muscled out of games, I don't know where this misconception about him being unphysical comes from. Just because he falls over when somebody breathes on him in an attempt to win a free kick doesn't mean he can't mix it when necessary. When Busquets has screwed up it's either been down to complacency or misjudging a long ball, both faults which willl probably be ironed out of his game with more experience.
I don't know where this misconception that having one strong midfielder can help you win games against physical teams comes from.
I mean, even if we play yaya there, does that suddenly stop every other player from being physical?
what use is yaya's physique anyway? he so rarely attacks an opponent like busquets, which is why the lanky fall-artist got into the team in the first place. yaya sits and waits for an opponent to come to him, which doesn't fit collective pressing. I wish he would attack opponents because then he'd be truly awesome. but it is what it is.
I've read some time ago where Pep was quoted as saying - the pivot should break up opponent's attacks, dictate the tempo and distribute the ball to the attackers on run... if you have one to break the play and another to distribute the ball then you are just wasting a mid fielder in your team!!
He thinks on those lines and clearly that's the reason he sees Busi as our main holding mid-fielder... But Masch doesn't fit into that description, so I don't really understand Pep's affection for him! Of course he might have that shade to his game but it's never been his main strength till date to my knowledge
yaya can distribute the ball well enough, that's not a problem, but he can't mix it in a short-passing attack like busquets.
yaya has great control and dribbling and rarely gives the ball away but he often moves it sideways or backwards. busquets has a better short and mid-range pass, so he can move the ball forward faster and in more varied situations than yaya can. and of course he can make forward runs, with xavi dropping back into the role of volante. this extra movement adds something to our attacking play.
none of these problems (except maybe passing) are terminal but yaya has not really improved as a player during his time at barcelona. he's as awesome now as he was when he arrived. and it's obvious he's not pep's kind of DM either. he's also looked very lazy at times this season, been a serial underperformer since the pre-season finished, and his agent is a monumental cockfag. when you add that all up, it means yaya will leave.
but he will leave with his head held very high IMO. I hope he goes on to great success elsewhere, and I hope he dumps his agent.
regarding badger, his short-range passing is about as good as yaya's, his long-range is much worse but his medium-range passing is much stronger. and he's a far far superior DM, capable of being both a sweeper and a hustler, depending on what you want. the way he can choke the life out of opposing midfields (when the team engages in collective pressing) is so dominant, and his sweeping skills covering for others are immense. what he lacks in comparison to yaya is physical stature. that's not to say he isn't strong, he's very strong, but yaya's tall and magnificent in the air. badger may be a good headerer of the ball but we'll never find out because he's such a short-arse.