1 - Marc-Andre ter Ansplant

xXKonan

Senior Member
I always remember God_Serena's crusade.
Credit to him, he was here even during some of Stegen's worst moments defending him till the end. There was a lot of doubt with Stegen but it's good to see him turn it around seriously play like Goalkeeper we have envisioned him to be.
 

xXKonan

Senior Member
Not sure if Buffon is top 5 anymore.

I rate Mats higher than Oblak as he's a better all around keeper than he is.
 

DonAK

President of FC Barcelona
Ederson yet to get there, but he'll get into that top 5 soon enough too. He's a special goalkeeper with that cold killer instinct. Likely Top 5 for the years to come in no order;

Neuer
DDG
ter Stegen
Oblak
Courtois
Ederson
 

JerseyAddict

Well-known member
Ederson yet to get there, but he'll get into that top 5 soon enough too. He's a special goalkeeper with that cold killer instinct. Likely Top 5 for the years to come in no order;

Neuer
DDG
ter Stegen
Oblak
Courtois
Ederson

I wrote Courtois but subed him with Buffon just due huge respect to him.

I totaly agree with you

Neuer is the Wall
DDG/MAtS are to me now equal.
Oblak
Courtois
 

Messi983

Senior Member
Ederson yet to get there, but he'll get into that top 5 soon enough too. He's a special goalkeeper with that cold killer instinct. Likely Top 5 for the years to come in no order;

Neuer
DDG
ter Stegen
Oblak
Courtois
Ederson

That's top 6. :p
 

Neeraj

Senior Member
As good as he's been, there's just no way anybody comes close to De Gea right now surely. He is a MONSTER. I think MATS is still a level below that. But that's not an issue, because aside from De Gea and Neur, there aren't many better at this point in time.
 

raskolnikov

Well-known member
Atleast we finally have a solid goal keeper for a change for all competitions. Its been years since thats been the case. Post Zubi it was a mess with the likes of Hesp, Baia,bonano and rustu. Then we got some stability in Valdes. But he was always the weakest link but got a pass since he was a la masia product.
Bar a few big games he has only been great in tata’s season after which he got injured. Pinto was a joke back up and just there cause he was friends with Messi. Afterwards we get Bravo who was great in la liga but mats was still a liability in cl.
Last season Mats was mr Freeze but since then he has really stepped up his game and became a top 5 goalkeeper. And even if he got injures Jasper is a more than worthy back up goalie.
 
Last edited:

JerseyAddict

Well-known member
I know its subjective but De gea is better than mats, comfortably.

He is/was for sure, but this last few months/games MATS stepped a level up. If he keeps like this for entire season we could argue. Now I gave him some credits ;)

Neuer is IMHO still a Universe for himself.
 

JamDav1982

Senior Member
De Gea has to be considered better overall but if TS had been conceding some of the goals De Gea in recent weeks they would get over analyzed to fuck and some blame placed on him.

Overall this season TS has probably been best in world but others done it longer.
 

Ripsta

New member
He's as good a shot stopper as De Gea, still prone to doing the simple things a bit wrong. I still shit myself whenever he attempts to join in the passing game at the back.
 

Home of Barca Fans

Top